Chronicles of narnia mbti - Page 2

Chronicles of narnia mbti

Hello Guest! Sign up to join the discussion below...
Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 31
Thank Tree16Thanks

This is a discussion on Chronicles of narnia mbti within the Guess the type forums, part of the What's my personality type? category; Based on the movies (haven't read the books in ages): Peter - ESTJ Susan - ISTJ (Fe? Really? she's the ...

  1. #11

    Based on the movies (haven't read the books in ages):

    Peter - ESTJ
    Susan - ISTJ (Fe? Really? she's the quintessential PROVE IT character)
    Edmund - XSFP
    Lucy - INFP? Seems to have Si in there somewhere.

    Reepecheep - ESTP
    Eustace - ESTJ (so hilarious, I love him so much, but total Te-dom -- FACTS, YA'LL)

  2. #12

    Peter is typed as a TJ and Susan an FJ...hmm

    Lucy - ENFP
    Mr Tumnus - IxFx
    Peter - ESFJ
    Susan - ISTJ
    Edmund - Poor Fe/Fi
    Aslan - IxTJ?
    Mr and Mrs Beaver - ENxJ and ESFJ

  3. #13

    Quote Originally Posted by jennalee View Post
    Peter - ESFJ
    can you explain how he's Fe dom? :0 i had a lot of trouble typing him and didnt feel like estj quite fit so id love to hear why you think that!!

  4. Remove Advertisements
    PersonalityCafe.com
    Advertisements
     

  5. #14

    Quote Originally Posted by jennalee View Post
    Peter is typed as a TJ and Susan an FJ...hmm

    Lucy - ENFP
    Mr Tumnus - IxFx
    Peter - ESFJ
    Susan - ISTJ
    Edmund - Poor Fe/Fi
    Aslan - IxTJ?
    Mr and Mrs Beaver - ENxJ and ESFJ
    IxTJ for Aslan? Interesting. What are your reasons?

  6. #15

    Quote Originally Posted by bokuto View Post
    can you explain how he's Fe dom? :0 i had a lot of trouble typing him and didnt feel like estj quite fit so id love to hear why you think that!!
    When I last watched the film I thought Susan was more like a TJ than Peter was. She was the most cautious about what the outcome of the situation could be, which could be Te with lower Ne. Maybe he appears like an ESTJ because he was the oldest and therefore had the initiative to take leadership. I saw this more as Fe. I think taking a responsibility for other people, and making sure everyone gets along is Fe. It is hard to explain, but I think it was more clear when he spoke to Lucy. As for Si, I just thought their doubts about Lucy's discovery with the wardrobe was Si contrasting with Ne. Ni types were more like Mr Beaver (lol) who foreseen exactly what would happen if they went after Edmund.


    Quote Originally Posted by Pinina View Post
    IxTJ for Aslan? Interesting. What are your reasons?
    I didn't see much of Aslan, because I stopped watching it near that point. He was not expressive enough to be Fe, and also introverted, so IxTJ was a random guess.

  7. #16

    Peter Pevensie - ESTJ

    Quote Originally Posted by angelcat View Post
    Susan - ISTJ (Fe? Really? she's the quintessential PROVE IT character)
    Exactly. Susan Pevensie - ISTJ

    Quote Originally Posted by angelcat View Post
    Edmund - XSFP
    I agree with those function, but he is xNTJ.
    Quote Originally Posted by jennalee View Post
    Edmund - Poor Fe/Fi
    Yes, inferior Fi, ENTJ. No Fe in that guy.
    I know he is difficult to type, I know there are different opinions (maybe because of film/book differences, maybe because of the changes in his personality throughout the story), but he is neither ISTP, nor INTP and certainly not any kind of xxFP. I will not write a lengthy reasoning, this post is very good and explains it all perfectly.
    So Edmund Pevensie - ENTJ (and it fits both the book and the movie version)

    Quote Originally Posted by angelcat View Post
    Lucy - INFP? Seems to have Si in there somewhere.
    Yes, but I think ENFP. Although movie version might seem a bit more like an INFP. (Well, it doesn't make too much difference.)
    Lucy Pevensie - ENFP

    Quote Originally Posted by angelcat View Post
    Eustace - ESTJ (so hilarious, I love him so much, but total Te-dom -- FACTS, YA'LL)
    He is definitely xSTJ, no doubt about that, but I'm not entirely sure which of the two...
    Anyway Eustace Clarence Scrubb - ISTJ

    Jill Pole - ISFJ

    Caspian - INFJ ( definitely xNFJ)

    Aslan - INFJ

    Jadis/White Witch - ENTJ probably ( definitely TJ)

    Digory Kirke - INFJ? (or maybe INTJ? Possibly INxP? I'm unsure about this one)

    Polly Plummer - INTP??? (That's a wild guess, I don't remember her well, from what I recall she maybe used Ti and Si, but then it could also be ISFJ. I really don't know, but she is one of the central characters so I tried. )

    Aravis - INTJ (almost definitely, but I admit it's been a long time since I've read The Horse and His Boy)

    Shasta/Cor - ESFP (the same goes for him as for Aravis)

    Reepicheep - ESTP totally

    Tumnus - ISFP

    Mrs. Beaver - ISFJ probably

    Mr. Beaver - ESTJ probably

    Miraz - ESTJ
    Bad Bunny and INFJalltheway thanked this post.

  8. #17

    Quote Originally Posted by BlackArrow View Post
    I agree with those function, but he is xNTJ.
    Yes, inferior Fi, ENTJ. No Fe in that guy.
    I know he is difficult to type, I know there are different opinions (maybe because of film/book differences, maybe because of the changes in his personality throughout the story), but he is neither ISTP, nor INTP and certainly not any kind of xxFP. I will not write a lengthy reasoning, this post is very good and explains it all perfectly.
    So Edmund Pevensie - ENTJ (and it fits both the book and the movie version)
    That is a good analysis. Is this your MBTI site?
    Also, question to anyone, why is Peter being typed as a Te dom?

  9. #18

    Quote Originally Posted by jennalee View Post
    That is a good analysis. Is this your MBTI site?
    Also, question to anyone, why is Peter being typed as a Te dom?
    No, no, it's not mine. I'm sorry, that wasn't obvious. I just thought it's a good, detailed explanation.

    Well, Peter seems forceful and strong-willed to me, he likes to have everything under his control (that's especially obvious in the movie when he can't accept that Caspian might replace him as ruler). Of course he is protective of his siblings but that can be explained with Fi( and also just being a normal older sibling Lol). In fact he is very blunt, even rude when his authority is questioned. See: with Edmund in The Lion, the ....etc. long title and later as well, with Caspian in Prince Caspian, even with Susan occasionally, the only one he is spares is Lucy who is said to be his favourite. Actually even that could be a sign of lower Fi, often ExTJs (and some IxTJs) favor a few selected people they like while they are rude,distant with others.
    There was also a scene in The lion, the...etc. that could be an interesting comparison between Peter(Te+Si) and Aslan(Fe+Ni), it's quite indicative of their functions. When Edmund comes back Aslan is accepting, doesn't exactly scold Edmund rather preaches a few wise words. Peter would immediately scold him, but Aslan says something like "let's not bring up the past", so Peter just looks with grave expression but he is still distant in his welcome unlike Lucy and Susan, who both hug Edmund. (A Fe-dom who don't wan't to hug people constantly? Not likely. Ok, that was just a joke, but I really don't see much Fe in him.)
    Pinina and INFJalltheway thanked this post.

  10. #19

    Quote Originally Posted by BlackArrow View Post
    No, no, it's not mine. I'm sorry, that wasn't obvious. I just thought it's a good, detailed explanation.

    Well, Peter seems forceful and strong-willed to me, he likes to have everything under his control (that's especially obvious in the movie when he can't accept that Caspian might replace him as ruler). Of course he is protective of his siblings but that can be explained with Fi( and also just being a normal older sibling Lol). In fact he is very blunt, even rude when his authority is questioned. See: with Edmund in The Lion, the ....etc. long title and later as well, with Caspian in Prince Caspian, even with Susan occasionally, the only one he is spares is Lucy who is said to be his favourite. Actually even that could be a sign of lower Fi, often ExTJs (and some IxTJs) favor a few selected people they like while they are rude,distant with others.
    There was also a scene in The lion, the...etc. that could be an interesting comparison between Peter(Te+Si) and Aslan(Fe+Ni), it's quite indicative of their functions. When Edmund comes back Aslan is accepting, doesn't exactly scold Edmund rather preaches a few wise words. Peter would immediately scold him, but Aslan says something like "let's not bring up the past", so Peter just looks with grave expression but he is still distant in his welcome unlike Lucy and Susan, who both hug Edmund. (A Fe-dom who don't wan't to hug people constantly? Not likely. Ok, that was just a joke, but I really don't see much Fe in him.)
    I see. I don't remember the second movie, which isn't very useful for you. I think he was just mad at Edmund for his selfishness/disloyalty during that scene. I didn't see a distance in either Peter or Lucy's character, that was more so with Edmund and Susan. That is fair enough, but I noticed more use of feeling than logic, compared to his siblings. Just in my opinion.

  11. #20

    Quote Originally Posted by jennalee View Post
    I think taking a responsibility for other people, and making sure everyone gets along is Fe. It is hard to explain, but I think it was more clear when he spoke to Lucy.
    I'm sorry, I had not read this before I wrote my previous post so I want to add to my explanation that he doesn't want to make sure everyone gets along, he just wants to make sure everyone gets home alive and everything stays under control. In fact I remember it was Susan who got angry at Peter because he criticized Edmund and created tension. Basically Susan's feeling function > Peter's feeling function. I think compared to Peter Susan might seem more logical to you because she is more laid-back and cautious due to her lower Ne and possibly even a healthier Fi creates that illusion. But they are both logical and Te-users.
    About Lucy, you are right, but I've explained that in my previous post.
    Bad Bunny thanked this post.


     
Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Vampire Chronicles Characters
    By Wounded Bird in forum Guess the type
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 08-26-2017, 10:18 AM
  2. Narnia
    By Kadence in forum Guess the type
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 08-19-2014, 01:36 PM
  3. Tsubasa Chronicles
    By Swordsman of Mana in forum Guess the type
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 12-29-2011, 03:04 AM
  4. [INTP] Narnia
    By Mufasa in forum INTP Forum - The Thinkers
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 12-19-2010, 11:23 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:01 PM.
Information provided on the site is meant to complement and not replace any advice or information from a health professional.
© 2014 PersonalityCafe
 

SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0