Personality Cafe banner

1 - 20 of 29 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter #1 (Edited)
Hello everyone,

I have some issues with my ENTP friend, and I thought maybe you guys could give me some insight.

ENTP's have Ti as their second (parent) function. I sometimes find this difficult to handle. It is as if Ti is never satisfied with anything I say. Nothing I say is ever good enough. My friend will either find a hole, or argue, or go on a completely different tangent, without giving my idea any attention. She didn't ask any questions. She didn't use her Ne to see the possibilities in what I am saying. She listens for a very short while, and then her Ti makes a conclusion or judgment, and she makes the conversation go into that direction.

For this reason, I rarely talk about my ideas, my conclusions, or my theories. I keep them to myself. INFPs often have really good ideas. But, due to her quick Ti conclusions, she ends up taking the topic in a different direction or an argumentative direction, and it gives me absolutely no satisfaction to bring them to her.

I have found that in general, she either likes to debate or "teach". As an INFP, my Te is too low, so I don't like debating. I am the kind of person who always realizes "afterwards" what great response I could have said. My functions just aren't suitable to debate.

So, I therefore let her "teach" me. I let her take the role of "teacher", and I take the role of "student". I don't bring topics that I know a lot about. Instead, I bring problems to her instead or topics I don't know much about. This way, she can "teach", and I can learn, and there is no conflict. She isn't forcing me to debate, and she isn't shutting down my ideas.

But, due to this dynamic, I basically let her be the "smart one". If she wants to be the smart one who has all the answers, then she can play that role. I am okay with playing the role of the less smart one who learns from her.

But, here is the problem. I don't believe that she is smarter than me. We are equal. I have a lot of wisdom and a lot of great ideas. There is a whole side of me that she doesn't see. INFPs also have the ability to see the big picture. I often see an even bigger picture than her. But, I can't share it.

I guess, sometimes I get sad and frustrated that I am stuck in the inferior, student role, when there is a whole side of me that is just as smart, just as knowledgeable, and just as wise as her, sometimes more.

And it feels like there is nothing I can do about this.

Part of me wishes that we could be equal. But in order for us to be equal, she would have to develop the kind of listening skills required to let me fully express myself, fully explain the big pictures ideas I have inside of me, without interrupting, without immediately seeing any holes in how I expressed myself, without automatically jumping to the other side of some random debate, and without immediately taking the conversation into a tangent idea of what I said.

We can't force people to change. Is my only option to keep playing the "student" role? I can't change that "Ti quick response" mode she has. That is part of who she is. It is what makes her really good at giving advice when I do have a problem.

I think ENTPs have really strong strengths. But, all of our strengths also go along with weaknesses. The decision I have to make is whether I decide to celebrate her strengths and accept her weaknesses, or whether I try to fight against her weaknesses. I have tried to fight against her weaknesses in the past, and it was never successful.

She has a real need to connect with people. She loves people.

Can ENTPs connect with people on an equal level? Or do they either form a debating type of friendship or a teaching type of friendship? If you do have equal friendships that aren't debating or teaching, which types of people do you usually do this with, and what does it look like?
 
Joined
·
1,162 Posts
Can ENTPs connect with people on an equal level? Or do they either form a debating type of friendship or a teaching type of friendship? If you do have equal friendships that aren't debating or teaching, which types of people do you usually do this with, and what does it look like?
I had to do a bit of thinking, and well... I'm better at this since I stopped trying to, ah, help people, but I expect I'm still prone to what you described. My husband (INFJ) thinks that ball busting is an essential part of my emotional makeup and tends to give as good as he gets, my boyfriend (ENTP) is even more convinced by the excellence of his reasoning than I am by mine, my INTP friend likes to debate and discuss theory until the cows come home and my ENFJ friend is going through a lot of life changing stuff and likes having me as a sounding board/voice of reason.

Sorry. That's as good as it's going to get. But you can tell your ENTP to shut up and listen if you just want a talk or a good vent instead of a lesson. We're good at not getting offended.
 
Joined
·
1,162 Posts
And I'd say my relationships are mostly equal, but they do often revolve around debating the merits of something or interpersonal stuff that I try to view through different perspectives to see what might be helpful. I don't talk down to any of my closest friends and I try not to do it to other people either, but having to tone myself down is annoying and doesn't really encourage intimacy-- if someone can't keep up with me or, in the case of conversationally lower paced but deep thinkers, tell me to shut up and focus on [thing]... well, that's really their problem.

This is why I get called self absorbed a lot. I'm okay with that.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
4,281 Posts
If you can keep an ENTP interested they can be or do anything you want them to.

I can listen and identify like a pro.

Or

I can dictate for hours.

or

I can do both at the same time...

or

I can not be interested and make you feel somehow good about the
fact that I just threw you to the curb.

If I wasnt feeling nice about it that toss to the curb may feel like a brick in the face,
by way of logical belittlement. Shallow as it may be it is necessary from time to time.

One of the main reasons I so enjoyed being typed as an ENTP was the fact that
we are not type cast ..we can move around and be ok with stuff even shutting up
if we are taking it all in.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
30 Posts
I'm here as a best friend of an INFP who can't get on with ENTPs if her life depended on it...

But I agree with above, just telling the ENTP to shut up and listen, playfully even, works wonders. From my experience, it won't hurt them, you can only earn their respect by doing so.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
198 Posts
Just today I reconnected online with a tattoo artist I knew a decade ago who threw gasoline on me and then followed that up by trying to throw lit matches in my direction because I happened to be wearing a beanie that said Jesus on it and I had to jump out the second floor window in order to escape. I have more respect for that dude than I have for 90% of the people I know - what a cool guy!

Point is - even if you try to literally kill us in order to get your viewpoint across, that will just make us respect you. Just tell the person in question to shut the f*ck up and listen. Most people don't do that - which is why we carry on talking. Do it. Earn the respect of your friend.

Good luck!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
108 Posts
I let her take the role of "teacher", and I take the role of "student"
I see, well please don't think of the "Student" role as a lesser, on the contrary. Smarter people talk less, it is true. And since you understand whats happening with your friends short comings and then decide how to act, you are in fact in full control of the situation and seemingly smarter. I have the same issues your friend does, lol but I have no friends who deal too much because they can not deal with my intensity or drive to argue. so take initiative to say "Hay, you got to work on chilling the heck out."
it helps to have a key word when she runs on or changes direction and your not ready, "Boom Key word here" ...mine was "shut up" and still i us for those few who deal. : )

also we ENTP's learn from teaching, we have to hear ourselves work it out with input from others, so it's in her best interest to control her habit and listen when you talk. you will have to step up the "Shut up key word" and she has to step up her "Listening ability" and I bet if she practices you will see and appreciate the difference.

Can ENTPs connect with people on an equal level?
Or do they either form a debating type of friendship or a teaching type of friendship? If you do have equal friendships that aren't debating or teaching, which types of people do you usually do this with, and what does it look like?
Yes we can, but it takes work and we ENTP's have to cultivate our habits carefully and practice self control (we don't all try to)
I have found I adapt to any and every personality type.(but ENTj is the hardest to get along with lol because that's who I date, I love challenges more than debating and with Her I get both >: )
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
8,295 Posts
I have been friends with an INFP since childhood.
Though, as juveniles our relationship was trial and error.
As an adult I have learned to read her body language. She has learned to throw topics back at me.

If I want to stay friends with her, I have to be courteous to her needs.
Any mature relationship is give and take.

At the same time you have to express how you feel...
If my friends don't communicate issues, how am I suppose to know?

I respect my friends for telling me to shut it. :wink:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
Thank you so much, everyone! You were all so helpful!

The answer is clear: I need to tell her to shut up!! :) And I need to tell her when I want her to listen. Truly listen. I am sure that she also wants me to express myself. I am sure she would love it if I explained what conditions I need in order to be able to do this.

What I love about ENTPs is that they are honest and they don't get insulted easily. So, she too will respect my honesty without getting insulted. This makes so much sense. I can't believe I didn't realize it sooner. It took a bunch of people like her to point out what was right in front of my nose all along.

Thank you so much, everyone! This was so incredibly helpful! :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,939 Posts
I will say that an immature ENTP has a much harder time figuring out who is appropriate to debate with and who is not comfortable and that they do not have to be the one teaching. Figuring that out comes with time and maturity. I do not have any problem anymore adjusting my interaction to who I am interacting with but I did when I was younger. My best friend is an ISFJ and I know not to debate with her because she takes it personally. Her INFP husband is even more sensitive to people hurting his feelings, so I am even more careful with him, although he is much better at arguing ideas and theories than my friend (actually my best friend hates theories and almost always will pull the conversation to a very concrete topic-that is why I was almost laughing when she claimed she was an INFJ-she is glaringly a Sensor). I am guessing your friend recognizes that you are good at expressing ideas and theories and takes that as "debate away" but I find INFPs like to get out all their ideas first and then discuss them over the way ENTPs do it by forming their theories as their mouths are moving and using the back and forth to solidify it more.

As discussed, direct approach is best when wanting to discuss something with an ENTP.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,549 Posts
Thank you so much, everyone! You were all so helpful!

The answer is clear: I need to tell her to shut up!! :) And I need to tell her when I want her to listen. Truly listen. I am sure that she also wants me to express myself. I am sure she would love it if I explained what conditions I need in order to be able to do this.

What I love about ENTPs is that they are honest and they don't get insulted easily. So, she too will respect my honesty without getting insulted. This makes so much sense. I can't believe I didn't realize it sooner. It took a bunch of people like her to point out what was right in front of my nose all along.

Thank you so much, everyone! This was so incredibly helpful! :)
I'm incredibly glad that you received this feedback because it's absolutely true. ENTPs don't want to dominate and make you feel inferior; what we want is push back. That's how we learn.

ENTPs don't want to make you feel like we're better. We want you to smack us in the face with something new. You won't be reviled for that at all. Oh, and ENTPs have very few emotional buttons. Just be careful of the specific ones that yours has. Your ENTP knows you wayyyy better than you think she does, and you don't want warrior ENTP coming at you as a feeler.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,808 Posts
Hello everyone,

I have some issues with my ENTP friend, and I thought maybe you guys could give me some insight.

ENTP's have Ti as their second (parent) function. I sometimes find this difficult to handle. It is as if Ti is never satisfied with anything I say. Nothing I say is ever good enough. My friend will either find a hole, or argue, or go on a completely different tangent, without giving my idea any attention. She didn't ask any questions. She didn't use her Ne to see the possibilities in what I am saying. She listens for a very short while, and then her Ti makes a conclusion or judgment, and she makes the conversation go into that direction.

For this reason, I rarely talk about my ideas, my conclusions, or my theories. I keep them to myself. INFPs often have really good ideas. But, due to her quick Ti conclusions, she ends up taking the topic in a different direction or an argumentative direction, and it gives me absolutely no satisfaction to bring them to her.

I have found that in general, she either likes to debate or "teach". As an INFP, my Te is too low, so I don't like debating. I am the kind of person who always realizes "afterwards" what great response I could have said. My functions just aren't suitable to debate.

So, I therefore let her "teach" me. I let her take the role of "teacher", and I take the role of "student". I don't bring topics that I know a lot about. Instead, I bring problems to her instead or topics I don't know much about. This way, she can "teach", and I can learn, and there is no conflict. She isn't forcing me to debate, and she isn't shutting down my ideas.

But, due to this dynamic, I basically let her be the "smart one". If she wants to be the smart one who has all the answers, then she can play that role. I am okay with playing the role of the less smart one who learns from her.

But, here is the problem. I don't believe that she is smarter than me. We are equal. I have a lot of wisdom and a lot of great ideas. There is a whole side of me that she doesn't see. INFPs also have the ability to see the big picture. I often see an even bigger picture than her. But, I can't share it.

I guess, sometimes I get sad and frustrated that I am stuck in the inferior, student role, when there is a whole side of me that is just as smart, just as knowledgeable, and just as wise as her, sometimes more.

And it feels like there is nothing I can do about this.

Part of me wishes that we could be equal. But in order for us to be equal, she would have to develop the kind of listening skills required to let me fully express myself, fully explain the big pictures ideas I have inside of me, without interrupting, without immediately seeing any holes in how I expressed myself, without automatically jumping to the other side of some random debate, and without immediately taking the conversation into a tangent idea of what I said.

We can't force people to change. Is my only option to keep playing the "student" role? I can't change that "Ti quick response" mode she has. That is part of who she is. It is what makes her really good at giving advice when I do have a problem.

I think ENTPs have really strong strengths. But, all of our strengths also go along with weaknesses. The decision I have to make is whether I decide to celebrate her strengths and accept her weaknesses, or whether I try to fight against her weaknesses. I have tried to fight against her weaknesses in the past, and it was never successful.

She has a real need to connect with people. She loves people.

Can ENTPs connect with people on an equal level? Or do they either form a debating type of friendship or a teaching type of friendship? If you do have equal friendships that aren't debating or teaching, which types of people do you usually do this with, and what does it look like?
We definitely can connect with people on an equal level.
Have you told her about your frustrations? Chances are high (from what you say) she doesn't see the roles in your friendship the same way you do.
We enjoy the mental sparring which comes from debating. We want you to join in and debate as an equal. However, it's clear that you don't get such enjoyment from that. I like being able to think quickly and seeing what pops up. Honestly, half the time I go on a tangent and see where it takes me.

My advice would be to chat with your friend about it if it really bothers you. She probably has no idea that she's making you feel bad.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
322 Posts
Well I hope this issue is fixed. It just sounds like the friend is an ENTJ... it's hard to reason with TJs. Asking her to simply listen to you will not work. I've found out that it's best to just nod your head in agreement to them. I'd like to know what happened after you asked your friend to listen? Is she actually actively listening to you now? Or do you feel like she's still constantly invalidating your opinion?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,003 Posts
It sounds like you might need to assert yourself a bit more and be vocal about wanting a chance to express your own opinions. She cant read your mind, so unless you tell HER how you feel the relationship dynamic will stay the same.

Take into consideration that the way she confidently expresses her opinion doesnt imply she's trying to create that dynamic or that she "thinks" she smarter than you. That may be how you feel she thinks but dont assume that. If shes engaging you in the kind of conversations it sounds like she is then most likely she thinks you are intelligent enough to banter with her! We do NOT banter with people who have no clue on the subject matter because that is no fun at all. I think she thinks more highly of you than you think and if you tell her how you feel she would give you more of a chance to speak.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,549 Posts
Well I hope this issue is fixed. It just sounds like the friend is an ENTJ... it's hard to reason with TJs. Asking her to simply listen to you will not work. I've found out that it's best to just nod your head in agreement to them. I'd like to know what happened after you asked your friend to listen? Is she actually actively listening to you now? Or do you feel like she's still constantly invalidating your opinion?
Terrible idea. Listen to the ENTPs you've heard from so far, @dreamshadow.

And don't cast aspersions on the ENTJs, @xdae, lest you have the thrown back at you.

i will defend ENTJs to the death. They're some of the best people you can meet. Make a friend of one or two and see what you think.

Until that time keep your trap shut.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
322 Posts
Terrible idea. Listen to the ENTPs you've heard from so far, @dreamshadow.

And don't cast aspersions on the ENTJs, @xdae, lest you have the thrown back at you.

i will defend ENTJs to the death. They're some of the best people you can meet. Make a friend of one or two and see what you think.

Until that time keep your trap shut.
Sorry, I didn't mean to insult ENTJs. My family is filled with XNTJ types. I respect them and appreciate their vast knowledge. They're great at sharing their wisdom and explaining their points, but not so great at understanding opposing perspectives. I still think they're good people at heart- just very stubborn to debate with.

Trust me, I've asked my XNTJs to listen to me all my life and it's never as simple as that. The only time they truly listen to you is if you agree with them. I don't think any less of them because of that, but I do try to avoid arguing with them. I've learned that it's better to try to appreciate their wisdom rather than enforcing your opposing views onto them.

I agree with the other ENTPs that OP should ask her friend to listen. Though I'm curious as to what happens next.
 

·
MOTM May 2011
Joined
·
14,038 Posts
Yes, mature ENTP's are actually great friends and don't debate as much. I've had really good conversations with them. Really, one of my favorites of the 16 types.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
705 Posts
Hello everyone,

I have some issues with my ENTP friend, and I thought maybe you guys could give me some insight.

ENTP's have Ti as their second (parent) function. I sometimes find this difficult to handle. It is as if Ti is never satisfied with anything I say. Nothing I say is ever good enough. My friend will either find a hole, or argue, or go on a completely different tangent, without giving my idea any attention. She didn't ask any questions. She didn't use her Ne to see the possibilities in what I am saying. She listens for a very short while, and then her Ti makes a conclusion or judgment, and she makes the conversation go into that direction.

For this reason, I rarely talk about my ideas, my conclusions, or my theories. I keep them to myself. INFPs often have really good ideas. But, due to her quick Ti conclusions, she ends up taking the topic in a different direction or an argumentative direction, and it gives me absolutely no satisfaction to bring them to her.

I have found that in general, she either likes to debate or "teach". As an INFP, my Te is too low, so I don't like debating. I am the kind of person who always realizes "afterwards" what great response I could have said. My functions just aren't suitable to debate.

So, I therefore let her "teach" me. I let her take the role of "teacher", and I take the role of "student". I don't bring topics that I know a lot about. Instead, I bring problems to her instead or topics I don't know much about. This way, she can "teach", and I can learn, and there is no conflict. She isn't forcing me to debate, and she isn't shutting down my ideas.

But, due to this dynamic, I basically let her be the "smart one". If she wants to be the smart one who has all the answers, then she can play that role. I am okay with playing the role of the less smart one who learns from her.

But, here is the problem. I don't believe that she is smarter than me. We are equal. I have a lot of wisdom and a lot of great ideas. There is a whole side of me that she doesn't see. INFPs also have the ability to see the big picture. I often see an even bigger picture than her. But, I can't share it.

I guess, sometimes I get sad and frustrated that I am stuck in the inferior, student role, when there is a whole side of me that is just as smart, just as knowledgeable, and just as wise as her, sometimes more.

And it feels like there is nothing I can do about this.

Part of me wishes that we could be equal. But in order for us to be equal, she would have to develop the kind of listening skills required to let me fully express myself, fully explain the big pictures ideas I have inside of me, without interrupting, without immediately seeing any holes in how I expressed myself, without automatically jumping to the other side of some random debate, and without immediately taking the conversation into a tangent idea of what I said.

We can't force people to change. Is my only option to keep playing the "student" role? I can't change that "Ti quick response" mode she has. That is part of who she is. It is what makes her really good at giving advice when I do have a problem.

I think ENTPs have really strong strengths. But, all of our strengths also go along with weaknesses. The decision I have to make is whether I decide to celebrate her strengths and accept her weaknesses, or whether I try to fight against her weaknesses. I have tried to fight against her weaknesses in the past, and it was never successful.

She has a real need to connect with people. She loves people.

Can ENTPs connect with people on an equal level? Or do they either form a debating type of friendship or a teaching type of friendship? If you do have equal friendships that aren't debating or teaching, which types of people do you usually do this with, and what does it look like?
I eventually gave up having the ideal kind of friendship that I wanted with my ENTP friends. I wanted to be equals, they wanted to be teachers. I keep our friendships to the minimal now especially my ideas and thoughts. Just let them figure it out on their own. Even if you told them something and you were eventually proven right, it will still be bitter for them to admit it. That intellectually competitive streak is not up to us to "get rid of".
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,957 Posts
The only relationships I have ever had with ENTPs are (oddly enough) my Dad, my Brother, and a woman who moved to another state to get married.

As an ENTP, I am certain that you understand that arguing and bickering is just the normal way of things. There hasn't been a SINGLE NIGHT when we've gotten together that my Brother, Dad, and I argued about some piece of nonsense and then looked it up on the internet to find out who was right. Insanity. The woman I spent time with, we'd ARGUE ENDLESSLY until it was obvious that one of us was correct and the other needed to adjust their thought patterns. Was it terrible? Idk, I loved the fact that I could spar mentally forever and not hate her. I adored it. Was it taxing, yeah sure, but DAMN IF IT WASN'T BLOODY GREAT!!!! What I would GIVE to have a partner that could tolerate it.

Does that mean we can't get along? Hardly. I go hiking with my Dad all the time and we talk about the oddities and wonders of the world for hours on end. It's glorious. My brother and I go shooting and he shares his knowledge and teaches me. Likewise, I teach him a thing or two occasionally based on my observations. We get into some pretty damnable conflict once in a while, and it seems like we're going to kill each other, but after it's said and done, we get back apologize, and admit that we both made mistakes.

I wouldn't change it for the world.
 
1 - 20 of 29 Posts
Top