Personality Cafe banner

INFP/INTJ Breakup Blues...Help?

12053 Views 34 Replies 12 Participants Last post by  Delilah
My INTJ bf and I seemed to be a good match. We had our lives and engagement ring picked out (He initiated everything and couldn't wait to marry me). Where I was loose in my goals and thoughts he balanced me. We were able to have intelligent conversations, watch dorky television, and try new things together happily. He was smitten with me and anyone that could see the way he looked at me knew it. I was in love and completely devoted to him.

What I didn't know was that not too long before he and I met he had fallen for a married co-worker that broke his heart. After Africa where we picked out the ring and had an awesome time, they struck up an emotional relationship again as she was going through a divorce. As she fought for him he became more distant but made the decision to stick with me because I was the better choice....after lots of lies and deception. We did have a small breakup in between but he came back to me after re-realizing how much he loved me and how much better I was than her. I accepted but I told him there were things we needed to work on and he was ready to gravel at my feet to fix what he did.

During all this time we were in a long distance relationship and after being with me and seeing how what he did affected me (I needed a bit of nurturing), he suddenly became very, very cold, told me I bored him and blamed me for his actions. He said that he wouldn't go back to this other girl, but he did. Immediately.

So my questions:
Do you think he's rebounding?
Did seeing how I was distant and hurt scare him off you think?
Do INTJ's feel guilt? I mean after swearing to try and lying so much and then just leaving me with the blame I wonder if he realizes or cares that all the things he did were hurtful.
And He's so cold now and refuses to talk to me...but do you INTJ's think he'll re-realize how perfect we were, miss me and come back? (Not asking because I want him back, but because he did it once before and if he did I would not oblige)

I can't stop wondering about it, but I know I can't ask him. He won't give me the time of day.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1 - 20 of 35 Posts
My guess: You are his go to girl when he wants affection and to give love when his co-worker isn't available.
Even if he does come back, please don't take him back. You were being used.
  • Like
Reactions: 4
My guess: You are his go to girl when he wants affection and to give love when his co-worker isn't available.
Even if he does come back, please don't take him back. You were being used.
erg. I know. I won't. But I guess I was still thinking that perhaps he was still confused and was scared of what it would take to make it better.
See less See more
erg. I know. I won't. But I guess I was still thinking that perhaps he was still confused and was scared of what it would take to make it better.
The thing is, he may have cared about you, but apparently his feelings for this co-worker are stronger.
He wasn't confused, probably just frustrated he couldn't have the one thing he wanted.
See less See more
The thing is, he may have cared about you, but apparently his feelings for this co-worker are stronger.
He wasn't confused, probably just frustrated he couldn't have the one thing he wanted.
You're probably right. It was just so selfish! And he probably doesn't feel any guilt. urgggggg so frustrating
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
the only time I go completely cold on a former loved one is when I really like them..

It helps me get over them.

Guilt is a feeling everyone gets, but when you have the ability to rationalize as a coping mechanism, its easy to shift perspective.
  • Like
Reactions: 5
the only time I go completely cold on a former loved one is when I really like them..

It helps me get over them.

Guilt is a feeling everyone gets, but when you have the ability to rationalize as a coping mechanism, its easy to shift perspective.
Yeah, the same day we broke up he completely blocked me from every mode of communication...lol. I don't blame him for moving on but I definitely don't care for coldness...even though it may be better that way. Thanks for your words. I'll just continue to move on without a "sorry"
See less See more
@JessJune
Do you think he's rebounding?

No.

Did seeing how I was distant and hurt scare him off you think?

No, I'd hope not, I don't think INTJ's as a whole are scared of those things, in fact I tend to want to meet those things head on and can barely stay away from the issue until it is resolved.

Do INTJ's feel guilt? I mean after swearing to try and lying so much and then just leaving me with the blame I wonder if he realizes or cares that all the things he did were hurtful.

INTJ's yes. Assholes? No.

And He's so cold now and refuses to talk to me...but do you INTJ's think he'll re-realize how perfect we were, miss me and come back?

I don't know. I'm sorry. I wouldn't dare tell you what to do or how to behave in this situation, only you know how you feel, do what you think is best if the situation ever presents itself. I'm sorry I've been very little use.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1

I don't know. I'm sorry. I wouldn't dare tell you what to do or how to behave in this situation, only you know how you feel, do what you think is best if the situation ever presents itself. I'm sorry I've been very little use.
No, that's very helpful! And I think I've learned my lesson. The last question is something that's gone though my head, just because it happened before. I know what I would do. Run.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
What do you want? You sound like you want him back. INTJs are known for being very cold after being slighted, especially by a former lover. You should take a lesson from us. He sounds like an asshole. You do not want him back. From what you described, his actions and his words all point to one thing: He's an asshole. Do yourself a favor and cut him off.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
No, I completely agree. What I want from this is some understanding of the situation. This was my very first relationship and it confused the hell out of me. I can still see all of the good but everyone is right. He is an asshole. Better luck to the new girl.
I believe you are best off considering the relationship over. The cold shoulder is a bit of a coping mechanism, I'm sure he feels guilty about leading you on, but now he is trying to send a clear signal that the relationship is over. I never did well in a long distance relationship. He probably doesn't feel like there is anything to discuss and has concluded that simply no longer communicating will be best for both of you. I know it hurts, but unfortunately might actually be for the best.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
No, I completely agree. What I want from this is some understanding of the situation. This was my very first relationship and it confused the hell out of me. I can still see all of the good but everyone is right. He is an asshole. Better luck to the new girl.
Well if that's the case then let me try. I have personally never cheated on a significant other in this way so I'm not completely sure but I'd be lying if I'd said I was never tempted (and the person I could have cheated with is not in my life right now). I don't believe he set out to hurt you but he just ended up doing it. I remember being very torn between two men but fortunately one of them was just not there, and it was also partly because I was not completely committed and comfortable with the man I was with.

So there's a problem with the relationship and there's a problem with me. I'm with a different man now and I'm totally ready to commit to him. The other guy can be right here and it wouldn't change my decision (and my feelings for him​ hasn't changed either- I still like him and would date him given the chance, but I know I've made a decision and this is what life handed me). I don't believe I'm an evil person but all I'm saying is that I could have done it. I don't believe he's an evil person but he might be a little less self-aware than I was, blaming you for his troubles (especially "you bore him?" WTF?). And yes, in his shoes I would feel guilty because he sounds like he really, really likes you, but just can't help being selfish. Blaming you might be a manifestation of this guilt. Because after all, if it's all your fault, he's not culpable? Right? Bullshit.

But all the same, the only reason he's torn between the two of you is because there are issues he hasn't worked out. Maybe he hasn't figured out that romance isn't just fun and games and excitement but being truly committed to making it work, "through sickness and health" and all that (you know, sometimes these conventional bullshit just start to make sense to me in these weird moments) Maybe you weren't completely right for each other and he was consciously or subconsciously looking for someone "better". How old is he, by the way? I'm sure it has to do with maturity too... I was wilder a couple of years back but decided to "settle down". Sometimes growing up is a conscious decision. Who knows. I'm not sure all of that made much sense but I hope that helped.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Do you think he's rebounding?

Somehow

Did seeing how I was distant and hurt scare him off you think?

No. I don't think so.

Do INTJ's feel guilt? I mean after swearing to try and lying so much and then just leaving me with the blame I wonder if he realizes or cares that all the things he did were hurtful.

of course we did. Though if the co-worker is by his side I don't think that he has a time for that. We usually get those feelings when all alone and reflecting our actions.

And He's so cold now and refuses to talk to me...but do you INTJ's think he'll re-realize how perfect we were, miss me and come back?

As long as he is busy he won't, It's hard to realize something if there's a distraction. And usually, after a break-up we tend to close our world to everyone in able to move on so we can stand firm and as if nothing happened.

IMO, you wanted him back. But it is better of that you move on.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Well if that's the case then let me try. I have personally never cheated on a significant other in this way so I'm not completely sure but I'd be lying if I'd said I was never tempted (and the person I could have cheated with is not in my life right now). I don't believe he set out to hurt you but he just ended up doing it. I remember being very torn between two men but fortunately one of them was just not there, and it was also partly because I was not completely committed and comfortable with the man I was with.

So there's a problem with the relationship and there's a problem with me. I'm with a different man now and I'm totally ready to commit to him. The other guy can be right here and it wouldn't change my decision (and my feelings for him​ hasn't changed either- I still like him and would date him given the chance, but I know I've made a decision and this is what life handed me). I don't believe I'm an evil person but all I'm saying is that I could have done it. I don't believe he's an evil person but he might be a little less self-aware than I was, blaming you for his troubles (especially "you bore him?" WTF?). And yes, in his shoes I would feel guilty because he sounds like he really, really likes you, but just can't help being selfish. Blaming you might be a manifestation of this guilt. Because after all, if it's all your fault, he's not culpable? Right? Bullshit.

But all the same, the only reason he's torn between the two of you is because there are issues he hasn't worked out. Maybe he hasn't figured out that romance isn't just fun and games and excitement but being truly committed to making it work, "through sickness and health" and all that (you know, sometimes these conventional bullshit just start to make sense to me in these weird moments) Maybe you weren't completely right for each other and he was consciously or subconsciously looking for someone "better". How old is he, by the way? I'm sure it has to do with maturity too... I was wilder a couple of years back but decided to "settle down". Sometimes growing up is a conscious decision. Who knows. I'm not sure all of that made much sense but I hope that helped.
I completely agree! With self-awareness portion. He's 24 and I'm 22. The thing that confused me the most was that he came back so sure once all the information about this other woman came to light. He was so sure that I was the one and so much better for him in so many ways. Before I found out, I did feel that maybe he was trying to find flaws in us and in me that would make his decision easier, but he found none. In hindsight, this is probably when his commitment started to falter. Maybe, when he saw me, and the damage he'd done, that was enough of an excuse. His way out.

He is obviously an asshole now. It is such a contrast from who he was before. Every weekend he came to visit me at school even though it was a three hour drive. He constantly told me he loved me, spoiled me with gifts, and took me on the vacation of a lifetime. We had "the better or worse" conversation after he brought up marriage and I went though every hypothetical situation that could be! Looking back, maybe he just didn't realize that his love for her was still there. If there was a flaw it was the distance. And she was enough to undo his commitment to me.

But back to the self awareness, he had a relationship before me that lasted about a year and they were engaged. She lived in a different country. He broke it off. I think you make a valid point. Maybe he just likes newness and hasn't learned that work is involved. How can someone that is so eager to commit also be so willing to run I wonder. But thank you for your post. It is indeed enlightening :)
See less See more
My INTJ bf and I seemed to be a good match.

Irrelevant (just because you do these things does not mean you are a good match, anyone can do this): We had our lives and engagement ring picked out (He initiated everything and couldn't wait to marry me). Where I was loose in my goals and thoughts he balanced me. We were able to have intelligent conversations, watch dorky television, and try new things together happily. He was smitten with me and anyone that could see the way he looked at me knew it. (Your emotions clouding your judgement) I was in love and completely devoted to him.
What I didn't know was that not too long before he and I met he had fallen for a married co-worker that broke his heart. After Africa where we picked out the ring and had an awesome time, they struck up an emotional relationship again as she was going through a divorce. As she fought for him he became more distant but made the decision to stick with me because I was the better choice....after lots of lies and deception.(RED FLAG) We did have a small breakup in between but he came back to me after re-realizing how much he loved me and how much better I was than her (RED FLAG). I accepted but I told him there were things we needed to work on and he was ready to gravel at my feet to fix what he did.

During all this time we were in a long distance relationship and after being with me and seeing how what he did affected me (I needed a bit of nurturing), he suddenly became very, very cold, told me I bored him and blamed me for his actions. He said that he wouldn't go back to this other girl, but he did. Immediately. (RED FLAG)
So my questions:
Do you think he's rebounding? (Irrelevant - he does not respect you - so why would you allow yourself to be a doormat?)
Did seeing how I was distant and hurt scare him off you think? (No, he is using you as a fall back while he searches for something else)
Do INTJ's feel guilt? (Most humans feel guilt {depending on context} regardless of MBTI type, however, based on the information given I think he is just waiting for something better to come along, and is using you as a filler for the time being, and if he is willing to do that, then I would bet he uses his own selfish reasoning and justifications for doing so and therefore does not feel guilty {regardless of whether or not he should}) I mean after swearing to try and lying so much and then just leaving me with the blame I wonder if he realizes or cares that all the things he did were hurtful. (Nope, it clearly looks like he does not care that what he did was hurtful. However, the question is why do YOU tolerate him lying and blaming you? {I know why, but do you? Your emotions clouding your judgement})

And He's so cold now and refuses to talk to me...but do you INTJ's think he'll re-realize how perfect we were, miss me and come back? (NO, and that is the best really (for you), you don't need a man who will treat you like that (you deserve love and respect), so it is best to let it alone, and move on. You need to realize that relationship was not perfect {you used your feelings to idealize him, which keeps/kept you from seeing the kind of person he really is} so that you can start to let go and move on to a healthy relationship.)

I can't stop wondering about it, but I know I can't ask him. He won't give me the time of day.
My opinions, based on your info. Take it or leave it.
See less See more
My opinions, based on your info. Take it or leave it.
I think I'll take it. I should have included that I was not trying to get him back however. Just looking for some understanding. And I do see the person he turned into, but before hand he was pretty ideal which is why I gave the second chance. After doing so he did fail me. I should have been clearer, but if was too long I didn't think anyone would read it.
See less See more
I think I'll take it. I should have included that I was not trying to get him back however. Just looking for some understanding. And I do see the person he turned into, but before hand he was pretty ideal which is why I gave the second chance. After doing so he did fail me. I should have been clearer, but if was too long I didn't think anyone would read it.
You made an honest mistake, then. I mean, it is your first relationship. My condolences. People often seem ideal at the start of a relationship. I just told my (new) boyfriend a week ago that "I like everything about you right now." "right now" is the key, I think. Their flaws eventually bite us in the ass.

Talk here more if you need more time. Closure is good.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Unfortunately, I have only one answer: You were not better than anybody and your relationship was quite mediocre. Blame games and rationalization efforts are nothing but a delusion... Move on.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I completely agree! With self-awareness portion. He's 24 and I'm 22. The thing that confused me the most was that he came back so sure once all the information about this other woman came to light.
That's something I could see, within an INTJish context. Using 'reason' to talk yourself into something, even though you don't really want to do it. We're supposedly notorious for deluding ourselves in that way and using the 'logic' or 'pragmatic' aspects of things to suppress the emotional things that (some of us) are bad at dealing with, or just don't want to admit to because we can't explain them, can't justify them, or don't like where they threaten to take us in life. Please don't take this personally as it really doesn't mean there's anything 'wrong' with you. By the sounds of it, all it means is he's either unhealthy or he has some issues he really hasn't worked out in himself yet. Unfortunately, you got caught in that crunch set up by his immaturity. Or his dishonesty. It's really unfair, but you seem to have been a casualty of some denial process he was caught up in within himself.

Maybe, when he saw me, and the damage he'd done, that was enough of an excuse. His way out.
TBH, it sounds to me like he does feel guilt - as he probably should. But he's been dealing with it by projecting it all outwards onto you, allowing himself to blame YOU for ways he should be feeling about his own self. And probably is, but he doesn't seem to have the courage or integrity to just wear that himself. He's trying to make you carry it.

How can someone that is so eager to commit also be so willing to run I wonder.
Instant-gratification junkie maybe? He also seems like someone who can't face facing himself, so he just takes off from any situation that shows him something he's not willing to see.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1 - 20 of 35 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top