Personality Cafe banner

1 - 1 of 1 Posts

675 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Jane - ISFP - Favorite literary heroine ever, and one of the first ones from fiction I really related to as an ISF/TP myself, though I feel I’d be way more suspicious of Mr. Rochester’s bizarre behaviors and dark secrets than she is, and start badgering him with tons of questions about what the hell was really going on in the North tower, and threaten to leave if he didn’t tell the truth and stop beating around the bush.

Mr. Rochester - Unhealthy ENTJ with mild-moderate manic depressive, NPD, and histrionic traits, though he genuinely gets a lot better at the end and mellows out - I have such a love/hate relationship with this character! I know he was a controlling, deceitful, and somewhat manipulative ass who Jane deserved better than. But he still loved Jane for who she was, respected her intelligence, and generally speaking, thought he meant well in his own entitled and delusional way. That’s not an excuse for his bad choices, or something that makes Jane obligated to forgive him or take him back, but it’s impossible to not be incredibly sympathetic towards someone like him who has an unconsciously pathological self-sabotaging and damaging desire to control everyone and everything around him to run away from his problems and live a better life because he has no self-worth or control over his own life in his situation in life, and because Jane loves him it’s hard to not to fall in love with him in spite of his flaws his anyway just like she does. I suppose Rochester is one of those problematic fictional characters who I just hate to love, even though I’d never date or marry someone like him in real life either, but I can relate to a lot of aspects of his character. With Heathcliff and the Phantom I just loved to hate them because they were so good at being bad guys, though, admittedly, the Phantom had something of a redemptive moment at the end of TPOTO.

Bertha - She’s insane, and she has zero lines in the novel, so who knows? From Mr. Rochester description of her, though, which, admittedly may be somewhat biased and one-sided, I’d guess unhealthy ESFP/ESTP. I know about Wild Saragossa Sea, and I’ve thought about reading it because Bertha’s plight is tragic, though I doubt she’s completely blameless for their problems either. However, many people who have read it say that it completely ruined Rochester’s and Jane’s characters, and Bertha still seemed like an underdeveloped caricature anyway.

Mrs. Fairfax - ISTJ

Adele - ESFP

St. John (Sin Juhn) Rivers - Unhealthy and misanthropic INFJ

Diana Rivers - ESFJ

Mary Rivers - ISFJ

Blanche Ingram - Snotty ESFJ

Lady Ingram: Snotty ESTJ

Richard Mason : There was never enough of his character for me to analyze, but I’m going to guess he possibly could have been an ISFJ because he cares about Rochester, and his sister, gets described as a pushover, and tries to put a stop to Rochester’s attempt to dupe Jane into a bigamous marriage.

Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë -

Heathcliff - Unhealthy INTJ with traits of ASPD

Catherine Earnshaw - Unhealthy ENFP with traits of NPD and mild manic depression

Ellen “Nelly” Dean - Snarky ISFJ

Hindley Earnshaw - Unhealthy ESTP with traits of alcoholism and NPD

Isabella Linton - Naive INFP - Poor girl! I felt so sorry for her.

Linton Heathcliff - ISFJ

Catherine Linton - ESFJ

Hareton Earnshaw - ISFP

Edgar Linton - Cowardly, though loving and generally well-meaning ISFJ

Anna Karenina:

Anna Karenina - Unhealthy ENFJ with NPD traits

Count Vronsky - ESTP

Konstantin Levin - ISFJ

Alexei Karenin - Unhealthy and socially/emotionally repressed ISTJ

Stiva Oblonsky - Unhealthy ESTP with NPD traits

The Phantom of the Opera by Gaston Leroux -

Erik/The Phantom : Unhealthy INTJ with traits of manic depression, NPD, and some ASPD

Christine Daaé - Very naive ISFJ

Raoul De Chagny - ISTJ

Meg Giry - ESFP

Madame Giry - ISTJ

Gilles Andre and Richard Firmin - Idiotic ESFJs

La Carlotta - Unhealthy ESFP with grandiose type NPD

I’ve just started Gone With The Wind, and I’m not even halfway through yet, so I don’t want the entire thing spoiled. However, so far I think Rhett and Scarlett are both ESTPs with NPD traits, Ashley Wilkes is an ISTJ, and Melanie Hamilton is an INFP.
1 - 1 of 1 Posts