Personality Cafe banner

MBTI Version: Would you rather?

3661 Views 13 Replies 14 Participants Last post by  ScientiaOmnisEst
Would you rather:

1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.

You can add "Would you rather" questions to this poll if you want to. I might be adding some as well.
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
Bolding what I would choose.

1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?

I would rather go one on one.

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.

I would rather be listened to than to just be rejected, but I also would find it illogical to shove it up someone's face.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.

I prefer working alone, but if I had the choice between a creative partner and a bossy one, I would choose the former. It gives more opportunities and possibilities. When I think more about it though, I think I would be much more productive if I had someone who tried to push the project further. But believing everything I do is wrong, and not allowing me to make any decisions, would be unacceptable to me. I work generally quite well with healthy xxTJs who are open for new ideas. (No, not all xxTJs or SJs are ignorant to new things.)

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)

Why is the INTJ necessarily male? Just curious. I would choose the former because I don't want to get physical with anyone without being emotionally close to them and they to me. I also don't know much about physics.

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.

This one is quite hard. In the end, I landed on the amount of people.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.

I don't want to overdominate someone helpless.
See less See more
1. If the ESTP is so physically strong, how can I beat them up in the first place? Do you mean attempt to beat up? Anyway I’d beat up the INTP because who says the ENFJ would even care/do anything? Even if they did I’m a fast runner ;D

2. I would rather debate against an xNTP and lose every time—that would be less frustrating than the other option and it would be a chance to learn something.

3. I’d choose to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrained INFP—I don’t mind taking charge of a project if I need to and I definitely prefer it to being bossed around by someone else.

4. This question is so weird because there are so many different random details about each choice xD I guess I would choose the first option.

5. Both of these choices obviously suck, but I would choose to kill the 12 genius NTs. Since the difference in numbers between the SJs and NTs is so extreme, the only logical reason for choosing to save the NTs would be the chance that due to their genius one of them might someday create something tremendously helpful/useful to humanity. Even though that’s a definite possibility, I don’t think the chances of that happening are great enough to justify keeping them alive simply for that reason (after all, being a “genius” doesn’t always mean you have the desire or drive to do anything with that intelligence).

6. What type of domination are we talking about here? :crazy: My answer would depend on that...
See less See more
Would you rather:

1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?

Fight the ESTP, sounds more like fight club. My ESTP daughter and I like to try and do sneak attacks where we take each other down.

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.

Debate with the ENTPs but I have never felt like I debate with ENTPs I usually feel more like my interactions are an exchange of different perspectives.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.

Kinda tough call. I like to work under competent bosses, but the micromanaging actually sounds counter productive. In this scenario I pick the INFP.

BUT in RL my boss is ESTJ he does not micromanage, if he trusts your ability he is lax and chill. So I would rather work under him then a scatter brain. But never a micromanager.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)

I will just skip both. I am dumb about physics but also would rather not screw someone I am not attracted to. (This question is rather bias, of course its an idiot ESFP and an ugly INTJ in this scenario)

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.

Lowest casualty count. So the 12 NTs (theres still other genius' why should those ones be spared but 1200 die)

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.

How about I let an ENTJ think they are dominating me and then flip the script (I think I have done that before IRL)
See less See more
1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?


I'd probably get my ass beat in either situation, so I'll save my dignity and take a pounding from the obviously stronger ESTP.

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.


I'd find it fun probing the morality of the SFJs. I usually stop caring at some point if my arguments are getting through or not and just go into prodding mode.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.


The INFP for sure, not only would they be more interesting to interact with, but I'd probably have more autonomy with them than I would with the ESTJ.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)


The ESFP. If she is interested in the subject matter, that is really all that matters. It can be fun answering questions and entertaining lay people with your knowledge.

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.


I'd save the 1200. The world has nearly 7 billion people in it, there are still plenty of geniuses to go around.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.


No mercy on the INFP.
See less See more
1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?

I'll fight the ESTP. We'll beat each other up and clear the air, then there'll be no hard feelings. I'm not, however, taking my chances against the wrath of the ENFJ.

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.

Debate with the xNTP because I do it everyday anyway. Besides, I have no problem losing a debate if I'm actually wrong and someone can prove it to me. Debating with an xSFJ like that sounds emotionally exhausting.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.

I'll work with the scatterbrain INFP, whatever, I'll just do their work instead if they can't keep up. But I honestly hate being restricted in the work I do.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.

I'll just talk with the ESFP about physics because who said I want to get physical with anyone? Besides, being 'dumb' doesn't equal 'being unwilling to learn'

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.

Okay, this one's actually hard. I guess I'll save the 1200 SJs because I can't imagine letting an ISFJ die.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.

Since I am an INFP - get overdominated by an ENTJ. It kinda depends on the context, but I suppose I'll take it the fun way.
See less See more
Would you rather:

1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?

Why am I beating these people up anyways?

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.

It'd be more frustrating to be rejected for no good reason that to lose because you're actually wrong, so definitely the NTP.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.

I can't stand ESTJs like the one described here. I'd take the INFP any day.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)


5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.

I don't care how genius those NTs are, they aren't worth 1200 other people.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.
See less See more
1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?


I'd shred the INTP, and outrun the ENFJ.

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.


Oh boy, I've ben in the second scenario way too much, so I'd debate with the xNTP.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.


The ESTJ, because I'd constantly fuck things over intentionally until he lets me decide.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)


I'd go with the ESFP and spout as much bullshit as possible and try to get them to believe it.

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.


12 genius NTs.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.


Overdominate the INFP, never been a fan of being put down.
See less See more
1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?
Knock out INTP quickly and leave the scene before ENFJ arrives.

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.
That's basically the story of my life, so why not.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.
They'll see the error of they're ways eventually, also I wouldn't have to pick up INFP's slack, and I certainly wouldn't be doing jack shit on the project at all.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
INTJs are supposed to be fast learners right? ;^)

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.
I'd like to think it's the same ones gloating in 2.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.
Second volume of the story of my life.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?

Eh. I don't need any injuries. Besides, I have an epee and a euphonium as weapons.

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.
I am an INTP. The argument would go on forever.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.
I always complete projects at school myself anyhow.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)
I couldn't stand somebody not understanding the topic at hand.

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.
No remorse.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.
I do it anyway.
See less See more
1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away

Preferably no one, as I am shrimpy and physically fragile. Though I do have a white belt in Tai Kwon do. His ENFJ buddy might not even be necessary in this case.

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.

As long as their point is genuinely more valid. I'm impressed when I lose an argument to someone with better points than me. As long as that someone isn't pulling bull points out of their ass and thinking I'm not noticing. Which a majority of the xNTPs I've met have done.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.

Whoever is more likely to have the motivation and push to gets the project done. I always lead projects so it'd be a brow-to-brow fight for who makes the calls, something I've yet to experience.

(casually skips question 4)

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.

12 because utilitarianism. So what if they're genius, that provides them with some pedestal over 1200 other individuals?

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.

But I'd be nice about it and buy them bubble tea occasionally.
See less See more
1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?
I know my reversed functions are going to hand me my a** one way or another. Let's do this...rolls up sleeves

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.
Although I will lose more often than not, I'd rather engage an xNTP than an xSFJ since the xNTP is going to back their statements with facts and figures. Even if it's all bs'ed, at least the exchange will improve my debating skills. I'm getting something out of it either way.

3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.
I'll delegate the INFP to generating ideas and finalizing the project design. I'll do the research and data compilation.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)

Gosh, hate both options. I guess I'd rather yap with the ESFP than have unconnected sex. :bored:

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs, Or kill 12 genius NTs.
Sorry to those 12 genius NTs, but some of the 1200 SJs are bound to propagate additional genius NTs so they must be spared. Your deaths shall be avenged through their living.

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ Or overdominate a helpless INFP.
Don't worry, I'm a gentle but firm lover...:blushed:
Now where's that red string, I just had it a minute ago?!
See less See more
Would you rather:

1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?
:th_Jttesur:

2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.
-Tremendously more thrilling to have my arse roasted by xNTPs. At least we're happily mentally sparring and even if it's unlikely that i'll outwit them, the process will be amusing & my opinions aren't dismissed.
Bonus: Hanging around them might improve my sass level.



3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.
Aye.

4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.
(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)
both sound ok honestly as long as ESFP is genuinely eager about physics & simply refuses to talk about anything else which I doubt. Or we can just casually switch the subject to aliens/movies/celebrities/anything we both like etc. And if INTJ & I are truly into each other, then let's get it on?

5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.
*sets everyone free*:triumphant:*is actually an undercover agent infiltrating the enemy to sabotage their plan*
*or maybe kills self*

6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.
-No way am I dominating over any cutie patootie INFPs. I'd toss marshmallows & drown ENTJ with adoration to hopefully thaw their dominant psyche a little, or maybe just let ENTJs work their natural commanding mastery on me since I'm fine with it & tackle whatever comes as an invitation to have fun. Maybe even collab with INFP while going about it :hugs:
See less See more
Would you rather:


1. Beat up a physically strong ESTP who will beat you up
Or beat up an INTP (average strength) with a physically strong ENFJ only a block away?

Fight the ESTP because I'm a masochist like that.


2. Debate against an xNTP and lose everytime and they shove it into your face
Or debate against an xSFJ and they reject every argument you make because the arguments are either immoral or they don't understand them or both.

Debate the SFJ; I can deal with not being listened to and even being called immoral - I'd prefer not to deal with having my own stupidity rubbed in my face. I can do that to myself.


3. Have to work on a highly structured project with a scatterbrain INFP
Or work with an ESTJ who doesn't let you decide anything because he believes you are doing everything wrong.

Eh, submit to the ESTJ. The frustration would probably be worth the success in the end.


4. Talk with an ESFP (hot but dumb) about physics (the science) and it doesn't get physical (sexual)
Or get physical with an INTJ (smart but ugly) but don't talk with him about physics.

(Btw the descriptions are not to be generalized)

Chat with the ESFP. I look more intelligent than I actually am, plus I really don't care about being physical.


5. In a hostage situation, kill 1200 SJs,
Or kill 12 genius NTs.

12 genius NTs. Because.


6. Get overdominated by an ENTJ
Or overdominate a helpless INFP.

:<

Neither?

Probably get overdominated. Both would suck but this would suck less.
See less See more
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top