Personality Cafe banner

1 - 20 of 14053 Posts

·
Banned
Joined
·
6,762 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Here, feel encouraged to ask as many questions on relationships or love or sex or dating with INTJs as you see fit, And we'll get around to answering as many as our 'cold, little robot hearts' can manage.
:laughing:

Remember, though, we're just here to give advice, it's up to you to take action. :wink:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
361 Posts

·
Registered
INTP sp/so 9w1 6w5 4w5
Joined
·
5,424 Posts
Here, feel encouraged to ask as many questions on relationships or love or sex or dating with INTJs as you see fit, And we'll get around to answering as many as our 'cold, little robot hearts' can manage.
:laughing:

Remember, though, we're just here to give advice, it's up to you to take action. :wink:
Shouldn't the title say "Questions"? :mellow:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
361 Posts
A relationship question...
Do the personality types of your parental figures have any affect on whether or not you will pursue a relationship with persons of those types, regardless of how compatible, or not MBTI may say you are?
 

·
Administrator
ESFJ
Joined
·
22,401 Posts
Would you adapt your love language to someone who was more used to verbal affection than loving through doing, or would that sort of adaptation feel forced and unnatural?
There is only a certain amount of becoming an orange an apple can do before it's no longer a viable option. We are what we are no matter how we try to be what we aren't. Where's Yoda when you need him?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,754 Posts
Would you adapt your love language to someone who was more used to verbal affection than loving through doing, or would that sort of behavioral modification feel forced and unnatural?
It depends on how much and how often it would be expected of me. If I really cared for someone then I don't think the occasional verbalization would hurt but if I had to be forced to do it frequently for the rest of my life then that's just ridiculous. It would begin to feel like a chore and the very act in and of itself would make me begin to DISLIKE the person just for the reason that it takes so much work to be with them.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
6,762 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
Would you adapt your love language to someone who was more used to verbal affection than loving through doing, or would that sort of adaptation feel forced and unnatural?
We're not as inflexible as some of the other types (or even some INTJs for that matter) would lead you to think.

Honesty is the best policy, because it leads to improvements.
And we're generally obsessed with improving our relationships with those we care about (in a good way that it, I may have worded that poorly), so if we find out that our SO likes compliments, we'll try to keep that in mind and compliment more freely.

It's not that we dislike comlimenting other people, it's more that we don't really appreciate that it's important on a subconscious level.


A relationship question...
Do the personality types of your parental figures have any affect on whether or not you will pursue a relationship with persons of those types, regardless of how compatible, or not MBTI may say you are?
In an ideal world, people wouldn't generally think of MBTI as a means of checking how well you'p might get a long with someone (as obviously there's a lot of variance between people even of e same type to give a precise judgement).
If you have a parental figure that is healthy, perhaps you'd become an advocate of their type.

Personally, my parents are ESXJs, and they've ruined any consideration of me dating someone as loud or as rule-bound as they are.
But, if I were to meet a health ESFJ or ESTJ, en perhaps my opinion would change.

Most of the MBTI relationship stuff is assumption, which can either come from two areas:
- Previous experiences with the type.
- Representations from the type descriptions.

So, yes, parental figures can definitely affect what preference you have in regards to dating certain types.
Though, it'd probably be best if you threw out assumptions that types give.
The I in MBTI stands for Indicator, it's not a dictionary, if you follow.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,401 Posts
Would you adapt your love language to someone who was more used to verbal affection than loving through doing, or would that sort of adaptation feel forced and unnatural?
Yes, nothing warms my heart more than being someone else's bitch. I love coming 'out of my shell' and sharing my 'gooey' insides with a loved one. I feel so alive and complete. I need others to tell me that I'm expressing emotions and to tell me when it's "OK" to do so. I don't know how to manage my emotions and seek support because I am paralyzed from the waste down, especially when it comes to love, if you catch my drift. *wink* I'm emotionally ignorant of the beauty that unites us all wonderful and unique individuals and I cherish the day that the beauty of love connects our souls as one.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
385 Posts
There are two more posts now after FlaylexFayte's! I wrote my response after reading hers.

In what way is it difficult to say stuff like, I dunno, "You are so beautiful." and "I love your laugh." and "You handled that situation with such strength and composure. I'm so happy to have you in my life..." etc. ?

I'm honestly curious as to why it doesn't cross your mind to say such things, I guess? I hope that doesn't sound like a rude question. It just... takes 2 seconds to say something like that, and I'd wager it takes a lot less effort than doing a something kind. Do you think words can be empty and therefore that sort of talk is useless?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
361 Posts
Would you adapt your love language to someone who was more used to verbal affection than loving through doing, or would that sort of adaptation feel forced and unnatural?
I've tried, and it didn't work... My biggest problem with it, (other than what bethdeth said) is that even if I mean what I am saying I tend to come off disingenuously, somehow... And then the SO feels like I really don't care, and I'm just saying what they want to hear. Which is true in a sense, but not because I don't mean it, it's just because I'm hopeless and awkward at putting it all in words... And it all ends with me confused and the SO's feelings hurt... :(
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
385 Posts
We're not as inflexible as some of the other types (or even some INTJs for that matter) would lead you to think.

Honesty is the best policy, because it leads to improvements.
And we're generally obsessed with improving our relationships with those we care about (in a good way that it, I may have worded that poorly), so if we find out that our SO likes compliments, we'll try to keep that in mind and compliment more freely.

It's not that we dislike comlimenting other people, it's more that we don't really appreciate that it's important on a subconscious level.
That was enlightening. Thank you!

Yes, nothing warms my heart more than being someone else's bitch. I love coming 'out of my shell' and sharing my 'gooey' insides with a loved one. I feel so alive and complete. I need others to tell me that I'm expressing emotions and to tell me when it's "OK" to do so. I don't know how to manage my emotions and seek support because I am paralyzed from the waste down, especially when it comes to love, if you catch my drift. *wink* I'm emotionally ignorant of the beauty that unites us all wonderful and unique individuals and I cherish the day that the beauty of love connects our souls as one.
I'm guessing you were trying to be sarcastic here. That is one language I do not speak very well. ;)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,619 Posts
Would you adapt your love language to someone who was more used to verbal affection than loving through doing, or would that sort of behavioral modification feel forced and unnatural?
As long as I loved them I would definitely work on it :). It might take some effort at first to make it occur on a regular basis, but I wouldn't tell someone I loved them if it weren't true, or any other such verbal sweetness. So yes, I don't think it would be too hard to do so long as it were true :), and I think it would become more natural over time.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
6,762 Posts
Discussion Starter #17
There are two more posts now after FlaylexFayte's! I wrote my response after reading hers.

In what way is it difficult to say stuff like, I dunno, "You are so beautiful." and "I love your laugh." and "You handled that situation with such strength and composure. I'm so happy to have you in my life..." etc. ?

I'm honestly curious as to why it doesn't cross your mind to say such things, I guess? I hope that doesn't sound like a rude question. It just... takes 2 seconds to say something like that, and I'd wager it takes a lot less effort than doing a something kind. Do you think words can be empty and therefore that sort of talk is useless?
Well firstly, there's the issue of INTJs being generally very independent, we don't require compliments and we don't think of them as 'a big deal' as a result.

But, more importantly, a lot of INTJs are paranoid of complimenting and showing affection.
We're the sort that analyze the problems and variables and trouble-points. We can't exactly do that in this scenario because we're socially awkward enough, really.
For us, complimenting is pretty much the equivalent of approaching to the pretty girl in the bar. We can't predict how it will go, we just generally assume it will go poorly... Very poorly...

Another dilemma is our poor ability to word things and our inability to predict how others will interpret things.
I once told a girl that she had "big thighs".
What I meant was that she has a much more feminine shape than I had expected and her legs took me off guard for how appealing they were.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
205 Posts
I find it hilarious that INTJ's are the new "go to" people for relationship advice, given the way we are looked at from other types.

@MissJordan I thank you personally for making this thread. The amount of posts of late for this INTJ relationship phenomena is getting out of hand.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
6,762 Posts
Discussion Starter #20
I find it hilarious that INTJ's are the new "go to" people for relationship advice, given the way we are looked at from other types.

@MissJordan I thank you personally for making this thread. The amount of posts of late for this INTJ relationship phenomena is getting out of hand.
Yeah, it's pretty bizarre how many people we attract.

They just want us for our sexy, sexy logic...
 
1 - 20 of 14053 Posts
Top