@CourtneyJD - I get the terms "tertiary" and "auxiliary" confused! Blame it on my inferior Ti. Pretty sure I wasn't referring to any ExTPs in this post, and just meant "auxiliary"
My friend and I have written entire essays (among ourselves, of course) about the selfishness of Katniss. It really wouldn't be wise of me to bring that into this topic :/ Essentially she's a Mary Sue (but that's a given), but she also does a lot of things that I find extremely selfish (even though they're paraded as not being such...) We can discuss it over messaging sometime, if you'd like. I'm always open for character discussions.
For Clarke I was actually going to say that she
doesn't seem to have inferior Ti. While she does make some pretty stupid decisions, they aren't the crux of her character. She is also heralded as being logical, a good thinker, a strategist... which an ENFJ
could be called (someday...), but not ever, I think, an ENFJ in her teens. Maybe an ENFJ in a rare moment, but not throughout the whole show. I still say she probably leads with an introverted function.
I think it is also good to compare her to... any Fe-dom you can think of. Regina Mills (pretty sure she is accepted as one) is an ENFJ, and she is very independent. In some ways one could see her as introverted and anti-Fe in that she has no problem going against the flow of others emotions, and even tortures others. She spends a lot of time by herself, and doesn't seem to have a need for reassurance. But if you look closely she actually
does - she falls apart without Henry (and was just a mess before Henry and after her father died), she always had to have little spurts of people checking in on her and on her side when she was mayor, and I remember her saying a few times that she only ever wanted her people to see her as the good queen like they would have Snow White. That's an Fe-dom. Seeking approval, needing to have people on her side, being motivated to please people, but also to be recognized and loved by people.
I don't see that with Clarke. With Clarke I see someone who likes to
help people, but who isn't too concerned if they don't
like her. She is rarely on the best terms with everyone in her camp, but she is hardly haunted by this. She doesn't mention, "I just want them to like me," "Why does everyone hurt me," "Why is everyone so mean and cruel," "Why can't we all just get along." She knows why they don't get along. She understands that not everyone is going to like her. She doesn't seem to take even assassination attempts personally, probably because she understands that's the nature of her role (I do remember her taking the assassination attempt from Mount Weather personally, but she didn't take the other casual attempts on her life in this way). She doesn't think the Grounders are mean and cruel and hardly spends time to analyze why those in Mount Weather are so heartless and "savage" themselves - that's just the way they are, and we have to act to deal with that. She also understands what it takes for the alliance to hold together, but she isn't out there promoting mutual games for the Grounders and Sky People to get them closer together. She's in her head. She's making plans, she's strategizing, she's just dealing with what they have. Honestly it is seeming more Ni to me than Si, and I think I'm lending heavily towards INFJ with an assertive core for Enneagram for her, maybe even INFJ 8.
Just for good measure, you can compare her lightly with other Fe-doms. Mary Stuart, mentioned earlier, also a CW female protagonist in a higher position even than Clarke. She got assassination attempts very frequently, and it seems that each one hurt her personally even when they didn't hit the mark. Regina Mills, already discussed, seeking approval in a way that Clarke never does. Also, I even think Glinda from Wicked. As an Fe-dom I feel far from Glinda myself - I am
not shallow or unkind in the way she is, or at least i like to believe I'm not - but when I hear Thank Goodness, I can relate. I want to be loved by everyone, valued by everyone, at the "center" socially like Glinda is here... but I am also very aware of how that wouldn't make me totally happy, as Glinda contemplates in this song. I bring it up because... I can see Regina expressing the feelings in this song. I can see Mary expressing the feelings in this song. But I can
not, at all, see Clarke expressing these feelings. Clarke wants the safety of her people, the survival of
her people in the 100 especially, and I think she wants a better world on the ground, but I don't think she wants to be their "queen" or anything. Perhaps that is looking at it too closely, but... My thoughts still stand.
In conclusion: right now the argument for ISFJ is hard, but I do think the argument for INFJ is still pretty open.