Personality Cafe banner

21 - 27 of 27 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
653 Posts
Huh, 1 doesn't seem un-IxFP at all to me. Can you explain your reasoning?
1 is more about imposition - IFP is more often depicted as bringibg the inner life to the outer world: expressing that which is within, while 1 is less about turning a seen thing into an unseen thing and more about reordering the outer world. Just a more Pi-Je type of structure overall.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
684 Posts
my final assumptions now that i know more about enneagram:

ESFJ - 1w2, 2w1, 2w3, 6w7
ESFP - 6w7, 7w6
ISFP - 4w3, 6w7, 9w1, 9w8
ISFJ - 1w9, 1w2, 6w5, 9w1, 9w8

ESTP: 3w2, 6w7, 7w8, 8w7
ESTJ: 1w2, 3w2, 3w4, 6w7, 8w7, 8w9
ISTJ: 1w9, 1w2, 6w5
ISTP: 5w4, 5w6, 6w5, 6w7

ENFJ - 2w1, 2w3, 3w2, 3w4
ENFP - 7w6
INFP - 4w3, 4w5, 9w1, 9w8
INFJ - 4w3, 4w5, 9w1, 9w8

ENTP - 7w8, 8w7
ENTJ - 3w2, 3w4, 8w7, 8w9
INTJ - 5w4, 5w6
INTP - 5w4, 5w6
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
684 Posts
These are my guesses for the most common enneagram type and instinct type for each MBTI type:

ESFJ - 6w7 so/sp
ESTJ - 3w4 sp/so
ISTJ - 6w5 sp/so
ISFJ - 6w5 sp/so

ESTP - 7w8 so/sx
ESFP - 7w6 so/sx
ISFP - 9w1 sp/sx
ISTP - 6w5 sp/sx

ENFJ - 2w3 so/sx
ENFP - 7w6 so/sx
INFP - 4w5 sp/sx
INFJ - 6w5 sp/so

ENTP - 7w8 so/sx
ENTJ - 3w4 sp/so
INTJ - 5w6 sp/sx
INTP - 5w6 sp/sx
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,119 Posts
@typethisperson a few things:
ESFJ may very well be more 6 than 2 but I'm not sure. 2 can be taken to be describing even some of the more 6-ish general traits of ESFJs.

ENTJ and ESTJ should probably change places as 3w2 and 8w7 respectfully. 3 is more formulaic and 8 is more based on controlling the physical environment. It's possible that both would be 3 or both would be 8. It's even possible that ESTJ would be 6.

ISTJ probably is more 6 than 1 - I agree with this. However I believe it's INTJ that may actually be 1(w9) first, above 5w6. We don't get as many of them around here, but that's not to say are less common in the general population. INTJ did correlate with 1 above all in an early, casual Enneagram survey.

ESFP may be 2. Some versions of 2 correlate better with ESFP than others though.

ISTP is probably more 6 than 5. We probably get a weird subset of ISTPs in these forums that are more on the N side of things, and this is different from the general population ISTP distribution.

INFJ as 6 may be okay but the data collected (admittedly from a biased sample) doesn't support this. Again, like ISTPs though, they may be more commonly 6 despite the data against this proposition, because it was a biased subset that opted into these surveys.

INTP may be more 4 than 6. This could go either way.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
684 Posts
a few things:
ESFJ may very well be more 6 than 2 but I'm not sure. 2 can be taken to be describing even some of the more 6-ish general traits of ESFJs.
Most ESFJs are 6w7 so/sp, the so description of 6s is different to how 6s are depicted as being sp 6s. I will never understand why people say that 6s are the majority but are often on the fence with saying that 6 is the most common for ESxJs. ESxJs are literally the majority.

ENTJ and ESTJ should probably change places as 3w2 and 8w7 respectfully. 3 is more formulaic and 8 is more based on controlling the physical environment. It's possible that both would be 3 or both would be 8. It's even possible that ESTJ would be 6.
No because that would mean that 8w7s are common and they clearly aren't. If you'd say 6 then which one? 6w5 is described as introverted and 6w7 is described as ESFx-ish. I'm fine with changing ENTJ to 3w4 because it makes more sense compared to 3w2 since ENTJs aren't known for their warmth or helping others to succeed as well.

However I believe it's INTJ that may actually be 1(w9) first, above 5w6. We don't get as many of them around here, but that's not to say are less common in the general population. INTJ did correlate with 1 above all in an early, casual Enneagram survey.
Smh, these are probably mistyped ISTJs. Everyone but you says that the average INTJ is a 5w6.

ESFP may be 2. Some versions of 2 correlate better with ESFP than others though.
No.... ExxPs are pretty 7. 2's seem Fe-ish.

ISTP is probably more 6 than 5. We probably get a weird subset of ISTPs in these forums that are more on the N side of things, and this is different from the general population ISTP distribution.
6w5 is plausible, I guess.

INFJ as 6 may be okay but the data collected (admittedly from a biased sample) doesn't support this. Again, like ISTPs though, they may be more commonly 6 despite the data against this proposition, because it was a biased subset that opted into these surveys.
The data is BS. It is based on mistyped INFPs.

INTP may be more 4 than 6. This could go either way.
Why on earth would INTPs be more 5w4 than 5w6? 5w4's are the emotional 5's and INTPs have Fe inferior.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
567 Posts
Estp: 3, 7 -- 8
estj: 3, 8 -- 6, 1
esfp: 7, 2 -- 9, 6
esfj: 2, 6 -- 1, 9
istp: 5, 9 -- 6
istj: 1, 6 -- 5
isfp: 6, 9 -- 2, 4
isfj: 2, 6 -- 1, 9
entp: 7, 8 -- 3
entj: 3, 8 -- 1
enfp: 7, 9 -- 2, 4
enfj: 2, 6 -- 1, 7
intp: 5, 6 -- 9
intj: 5, 1 -- 6
infp: 4, 9 -- 6
infj: 1, 4 -- 5, 6
 
21 - 27 of 27 Posts
Top