Overrated:
* ability
* acceptance
* altruism
* assertiveness
* attention, focus
* autonomy
* awareness
* balance
* benevolence
* candor
* caring
* caution
* charity
* chastity
* citizenship
* cleanliness
* commitment
* compassion
* confidence
* conscientiousness
* consideration
* contentment
* cooperativeness
* courage
* courteousness
* creativity
* curiosity
* dependability
* detachment
* determination
* diligence
* discernment
* ethical egoism
* empathy
* encouragement
* endurance
* enthusiasm
* equanimity
* fairness
* faithfulness, fidelity
* flexibility
* foresight
* forgiveness
* fortitude
* friendliness
* generosity
* gentleness
* goodness
* gratitude, appreciation
* helpfulness
* honesty
* honor
* hopefulness
* hospitality
* humility
* humor
* impartiality
* independence
* individualism
* industriousness
* integrity
* intuition
* inventiveness
* justice
* kindness
* knowledge
* logic
* lovingness
* loyalty
* meekness
* mercy
* moderation
* modesty
* morality
* nonviolence
* nurturing
* obedience
* openness
* optimism
* order
* patience
* peacefulness
* perseverance
* philomathy
* piety
* potential
* poverty
* prudence
* purity
* purposefulness
* reason
* readiness
* remembrance
* resilience
* respectfulness
* responsibility
* restraint, self control
* reverence
* salubrity
* self-awareness
* self-confidence
* self-discipline
* self-reliance
* self-respect
* sensitivity
* service
* sharing
* sincerity
* spirituality
* strength
* sympathy
* tactfulness
* temperance
* tenacity
* thankfulness
* thoughtfulness
* trustworthiness
* truthfulness
* understanding
* unity
* unselfishness
* vigilance
* wisdom
I kid, I kid, those are all pretty good things. Well maybe things like 'citizenship', 'piety', 'reverence' or 'obedience' are maybe a tad overrated historically. Egoism looks odd in the list, but self-preservation can also be a nice thing if used responsably.
(source: Wikipedia, duh)