Personality Cafe banner
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
Their answers are hilarious.
 
I always thought Alice was an IxFP. I've never known what to think about Ethan, lol.
 
Alice would be xNFJ, I'm leaning towards. On III:

“Oppression is a theme in general … A lot of bad things have happened to people close to me since (II) and it’s profoundly influenced my writing as I’ve realized there will never be justice for them,” Alice Glass commented in a statement. “I didn’t think I could lose faith in humanity any more than I already had, but after witnessing some things, it feels like the world is a dystopia where victims don’t get justice and corruption prevails. I’m one step away from being a vigilante to protect people and bring justice to the people I love. I’ve thought about it”.
Sounds pretty xNFJ to me. I'd say ENFJ for her, the E being a guess.

Not sure about Ethan, based off the interview, I'll guess ENTP? Especially the NP. On the new album, they tried using different gear, and that seems like an "N" thing to do, new challenges. He comes off pretty laid back, tough to picture him as a J.
 
Discussion starter · #10 ·
Alice would be xNFJ, I'm leaning towards. On III:



Sounds pretty xNFJ to me. I'd say ENFJ for her, the E being a guess.

Not sure about Ethan, based off the interview, I'll guess ENTP? Especially the NP. On the new album, they tried using different gear, and that seems like an "N" thing to do, new challenges. He comes off pretty laid back, tough to picture him as a J.
What she said sounds like Fi to me and I'd bet money that she doesn't care anymore.

And it's a trend going around to use purely analog equipment. Ethan is amazing, but that's not necessarily N... probably Fe, if any function is to be held responsible.
 
Discussion starter · #13 ·
Alice Glass - (unstable) ISTP on drugs.
Ethan - INTP.
I'd like to know why you chose ISTP?

It's probably not a good idea to type based on lyrics, but Alice's lyrics are very Ne heavy. The way she got excited (eyes darting/wiggling around) talking about Helen Keller is a very Ne thing as well, judging by myself and an ENFP I'm close to. And why would it matter that she was a communist when going to an amusement park? She didn't answer the question in a very concrete way like an ISTP probably would. I'm still betting on ENFP or INFP.

As for Ethan being INTP. I can see that, but he's so ambiguous.
 
I'd like to know why you chose ISTP?

It's probably not a good idea to type based on lyrics, but Alice's lyrics are very Ne heavy. The way she got excited (eyes darting/wiggling around) talking about Helen Keller is a very Ne thing as well, judging by myself and an ENFP I'm close to. And why would it matter that she was a communist when going to an amusement park? She didn't answer the question in a very concrete way like an ISTP probably would. I'm still betting on ENFP or INFP.

As for Ethan being INTP. I can see that, but he's so ambiguous.
I understand what you mean about that she can be an intuitive. Drugs, in my opinion can bring out a lot intuitivism in an sensor. Its like a getaway for intuitivism. I think some sensors enjoy taking drugs because it gives them the ability to be intuitive. Just as it can make an introvert to an extrovert. She is very direct . She got this angry eyes and very ISTPish body language. She has good motoric skills, you can see that on the way she holds her hands (and that can be an istp trait) My mother and a close friend is ISTP (both with an interest for poems and literature) and beyond their self-control and straight to the point way of being -They have an ability to turn analytical observation into deep symbolism. And her anger comes across as an ENFJ loop. I have seen ISTPs have that before. An ISTP can control their loop (if they got) it. Just as her mood switches drastically between when she talks and when she performs. Thats my two cents


 
I didn't knew the existence of this thread,
fuck yesh they are my favorite band (or were, or are again,.. complicated)
Ethan is an NT, and probably an I, since he works "behind the scenes", don't know about the P/J, he seems to be kind of a hybrid. In enneagram he is probably either a 5 or a 9w8, sp/sx.
Now Alice, I agree with some people here, and I am going to say ENFP, she uses a lot of Ne when she speaks. And probably a 4 yes. Sx/so.
I'm waiting to type Edith, the new singer
 
1 - 16 of 16 Posts