Is it always because we feel bad for an object that we personify it? I am going to have to think about this.
Good question. I do tend to personify objects more when I'm feeling bad about them, or trying to consider my impact on them. But perhaps there's also a greater sense of responsibility over an object's fate, since they are usually passive and sometimes we own them.
I am honestly not the best caretaker for objects though--but I'm not purposefully disorganized. But it does bother me when they can't fulfill their purpose.
Sometimes I personify objects more consciously or for fun now. Like when I got my new sheets, I made up this mythology about how they imbue the sleeper with restful sleep, how they are made from imaginary materials, and magical. But that was mostly conscious effort.
But yeah, I go into a dumpster or a goodwill warehouse, and I tend to feel bad for the objects because they seem so unloved and they lack a purpose to others, and they just 'want' to be able to do what they were intended.
Especially sad is when an object has sentimental meaning for one individual, and that individual dies and the object remains. Like once I found a photo album of cats in an estate sale, and I just felt sort of angry and sad like that the family should have taken it (if she had family) because it was obviously really meaningful to her and now it would be sort of 'homeless' and no one would understand how wonderful it was...they would just think they are random pictures of cats, when clearly they were not.
But that's also just...some kind of existential line of thinking though--what gives things meaning, what is 'purpose' in this world. It's probably love or something. I mean, it made me happy that she could take pleasure in her photo album of cats, and probably in her cat. Really, that is a good thing. She loved and her cat was probably well loved, and that is just a little reminder/memory of that snippet in time.
Kind of reminds me of stories like The Velveteen Rabbit or Pinocchio, in which objects desire to be 'real.' But...it makes sense to me that they should be appreciated and loved, or else reformed.
The technique of kintsugi or 'golden repair' is also kind of cool. I do think it's a good idea to be concerned with the future of objects made, their durability, and their purpose. And an understanding of resources.