Personality Cafe banner
1 - 20 of 58 Posts

Swordsman of Mana

· Banned
Joined
·
18,883 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
just started it, and it's pretty decent so far, so I thought it deserved its own thread (some of the typings will be a touch different than they are in the movies)

Anakin Skywalker: ESFP 2w3>7w8>8w9 So/Sx (Anakin is more collected here than in the movies, not as reactive or emotionally angsty)
Yoda: INFJ 9w1>5w6>2w1 So/Sx
Asoka Tano: E?FP 7w6>1w2>2w? Sx/So (maybe So/Sx)
Obi-Wan Kenobi: ISTJ 1w9>6w5>3w4 Sp/So
Asajj Ventress: some sort of xxTJ or really screwed up xxFP, 4/6/8 Sx/Sp (unsure of order)
 
Discussion starter · #3 · (Edited)
Asajj Ventress: some sort of xxTJ or really screwed up xxFP, 4/6/8 Sx/Sp (unsure of order)
watched a little further, definitely Sexual 4.

Luminara Unduli: ISTJ 1w9 So/Sp
Newt Gunray: INTJ 5w6 Sp/So
Kit Fisto: ISTP 8w9>7>2 So/Sx
 
Discussion starter · #4 ·
Bane: ISTP 8w? Sp/Sx
Mace Windu: ISTJ 1w9 Sx/Sp
Clones: various types of xSTx Social 6
Padme: E??J 1w2 So/Sx (maybe 137?)
Plo Koon: I?TJ 1w9>5w6>?w? So/Sp
Aayla Secura: ISTJ 1w9 or 9w1, not sure of stacking

a few updates:
switching Luminara to Sp 1 (more cautious, more self-focused and less critical
Ahsoka is definitely ESFP
 
Bane: ISTP 8w? Sp/Sx
Mace Windu: ISTJ 1w9 Sx/Sp
Clones: various types of xSTx Social 6
Padme: E??J 1w2 So/Sx (maybe 137?)
Plo Koon: I?TJ 1w9>5w6>?w? So/Sp
Aayla Secura: ISTJ 1w9 or 9w1, not sure of stacking

a few updates:
switching Luminara to Sp 1 (more cautious, more self-focused and less critical
Ahsoka is definitely ESFP
Thank you for doing these! I hope to see types of Barriss and Satine. It's been so long since I've seen the series but this is making me feel nostalgic.
 
Anakin: ESFP
Ahsoka: ExFP
Obi-Wan: ISTJ
Padme: ENFJ
C3PO: ESFJ
R2D2: Doesn't talk, so you probably can't really type him. But I've always thought of him as an ENTP.
Mace Windu: xSTJ
Yoda: INTP
Palpatine: INTJ
Grevious: ESTP
Count Dooku: INxJ
Asajj Ventress: ISFP
Darth Maul: ISTP or INTJ
Satine: INFP 9w1 caricature
Clones: Base is ISTP but probably varies
Bariss: IxxJ
Cad Bane: ISTP
Good show. Also good damage control for what a lot of people didn't like about the prequel movies.
 
Discussion starter · #7 ·
Thank you for doing these! I hope to see types of Barriss and Satine. It's been so long since I've seen the series but this is making me feel nostalgic.
Bariss: ISTJ 3w4/1w9 Sp/Sx
Satine: ENFP 7w6>1w2>2w1 So/Sx
@Rebelgoatalliance
not all pacifists are 9w1s. Satine is more fiery, opinionated and spunky than 9w1.
 
Hey everyone! First post, so I just want to throw out my suggestion/guesstimates on which characters, besides the already established Anakin, Obi-Wan, Yoda, etc. Please feel free to critique and make suggestions to changing types with suitable evidence. Be aware those 9w6 things and others go completely over my head.

Trooper Echo: INFJ
Ahsoka Tano: ENFP
Asajj Ventress: ISTP
Shaak Ti: ISFJ
Captain Rex: ENTJ
Trooper Fives: ESFJ
Lux Bonteri: INFP
Commander Cody: INTP
General Grievous: ENTP
Hondo Ohnaka: ESTP
Luminara Unduli: ESTJ
Pre Vizla: INTJ
Trooper Boil: ISTJ
Trooper Waxer: ESFP
Duchess Satine: ENFJ

Read and reply, suggest as you see fit.
 
Discussion starter · #14 ·
Hey everyone! First post, so I just want to throw out my suggestion/guesstimates on which characters, besides the already established Anakin, Obi-Wan, Yoda, etc. Please feel free to critique and make suggestions to changing types with suitable evidence. Be aware those 9w6 things and others go completely over my head.

Trooper Echo: INFJ
ISTJ

Ahsoka Tano: ENFP
yes

Asajj Ventress: ISTP
she seems Fi to me. maybe more ISFP/INTJ?

Shaak Ti: ISFJ
most likely, could be ISTJ

Luminara Unduli: ESTJ
some sort of ?STJ. not sure which

Duchess Satine: ENFJ
I see ENFP, but that could work
 
Asajj is INTJ.

Though I know he's not exclusive to Clone Wars, Darth Maul is a total ISFP. People get thinking type for him just because he's not always emotionally expressive and he's a mean son of a bitch so that would stereotypically look like a thinking type. His motivations aren't based in any sort of rational, logic/data-based approaches but rather intense personal emotions manifesting in grudges. *cough* Obi-Wan *cough* It was also his impulsiveness that lead to his defeat in The Phantom Menace.

Obi-Wan I believe is an xNFJ.

Yoda is an INTP.

Anakin is an ESFP. When he becomes Darth Vader, though, the trauma makes him into an ISTJ.
 
Discussion starter · #16 ·
Asajj is INTJ
I don't see Se as inferior, but I'll consider this typing

Though I know he's not exclusive to Clone Wars, Darth Maul is a total ISFP. People get thinking type for him just because he's not always emotionally expressive and he's a mean son of a bitch so that would stereotypically look like a thinking type. His motivations aren't based in any sort of rational, logic/data-based approaches but rather intense personal emotions manifesting in grudges. *cough* Obi-Wan *cough* It was also his impulsiveness that lead to his defeat in The Phantom Menace.
he is impulsive and holds a grudge because he is an 8. he's a mean son of a bitch because he's a sith

Obi-Wan I believe is an xNFJ.
definitely not. Obi-Wan is much more objective, step by step, relies on external systems of logic and protocol. he is ISTJ (FJs of all types are less formal and detached and show more of their emotions)

Yoda is an INTP.
]
possibly

Anakin is an ESFP. When he becomes Darth Vader, though, the trauma makes him into an ISTJ.
I see "original" Darth Vader as more ESTJ. not seeing ISTJ
 
I'm sure we'll argue till the cows come home about Maul. He's like, my favorite Star Wars character so my reasoning for ISFP is rather fierce. I could see 8. But INTJ is unlikely. Far too quick to engage with the environment. Ni-doms, especially for INTJ, are hands-off. Sidious is an ENTJ. He lets people do his dirty work. Maul just... Does things. He does not sit back with some big diabolical plan like the other NTJ's of Star Wars. Asajj I am not convinced of anything so I'm fine with other considerations.

Obi-Wan? ISTJ? I think Ni is what makes him methodical. But whatever.

Yoda is like... The INTP of INTP's. Lol.

ESTJ for Vader is fine.
 
Discussion starter · #18 ·
@SheWolf
I also fucking love Darth Maul. we can agree on that at least :cool:

Obi-Wan? ISTJ? I think Ni is what makes him methodical. But whatever.
his thinking is much more common sense, by the book and step by step like ISTJ. there is a certained grounded that INFJs lack (they're more interested in far-off theories, not as practical). if you're convinced of Ni, I would see INTJ before INFJ.
 
@SheWolf
I also fucking love Darth Maul. we can agree on that at least :cool:
He's such a vastly underrated character. He was about the only good thing to come out of The Phantom Menace.

Honestly, before watching Clone Wars there's no way I would have thought ISFP. Probably would have laughed at that suggestion. But, then again, when did his actual character actually show through? He spoke like, two lines.

But in the Clone Wars, he has so much more dimension. My argument for ISFP is his complete inability to detach from his emotions. There's no real logical reason to go after Kenobi. He doesn't just want to kill Kenobi, he wanted Kenobi to feel the same pain and shame that he had. He wanted to emotionally tear him down.

In fact, Sidious was able to make a weapon out of him because of his deep emotion and passion because that's what drives his very being. Once again, I see no weak Se in him, either. Inferior Se is a hesitation to engage directly in the environment and when it does, it's very clumsy; whether the Ni-dom is an Enneagram 8 or not. Maul's not clumsy with his environment at all, he just gets cocky and hell, his emotionality tends to throw him into some blind rage that ends up screwing him over.
I remember thinking "shit, this guy is an emotional mess" when watching the Clone Wars because that was just not what I was expecting out of him. But that just made me love him more. ;) Sexy beast, that one is.

his thinking is much more common sense, by the book and step by step like ISTJ. there is a certained grounded that INFJs lack (they're more interested in far-off theories, not as practical). if you're convinced of Ni, I would see INTJ before INFJ.
I see his Ni in his perceptions of Anakin. He told Qui-Gon the boy was going to be trouble. Qui-Gon literally tells him to "keep his mind in the present."
When would ever have to tell a Sensor this? They live in the moment totally on their own. He is a strategist, but that's Ni wanting to take the step-by-step action to achieve something in the long-term. An ISTJ would care about their immediate environment, right this moment. Obi cares about what things are going to bring in the long-term. He tries to pass on patience to Luke Skywalker and "trusting the Force."

As for Fe, he's very oriented to people, not necessarily Te efficiency. He was concerned about the effect of how the Jedi Council would view him and Qui-Gon when he takes on Anakin. He's pretty forthright with his feelings on things, though I find his morality is dynamic depending on the situation. I see no resemblance between him and Vader at all, honestly. In fact, he's pretty quick to notice when the "mood" of another is off. I see him as being quite emotionally attentive.
 
Oddly, Darth Maul does seem like a feeler. The bulk of his choices are based on his personal feelings and will act on them despite the lack of clear logic. He wants Obi Wan to feel his pain, wants him to suffer on such a deep level that he keeps him alive for that sole purpose. A T villain would probally have at least one logical reason for this. Mauls main goal is to HURT somone, not to earn something, not to become someone. At least, that is his first and foremost goal. I would say Fi, but really messed up Fi.

Oh, and not to spoil anything, but let's say when Maul's story picks up,some years later outside of CW, I would say the F argument holds.
 
1 - 20 of 58 Posts