I would like to thank @
Marvin the Dendroid for making the arguments I have long made and have grown tired of making.
Even among my fellow liberals it is rare to find men who have worked so hard to understand the female perspective here. Even among women I find a lot of arguments about sex work that I can’t support. “Choosing” to go into sex work to support a drug habit, or because it’s the only way for a woman to support her kids as a single mom, sort of illustrates the point that it’s a choice of desperation.
I agree with you that 'choosing' to be a prostitute because of a drug addiction isn't much of a choice. And, with my friend--I should add that she was also underage.
But I just think there are nuances, and it's complicated. Where I live, it's prohibited--and everything I've described happens still. @
Marvin the Dendroid was talking about laws that penalize the men who seek sex, but not the prostitutes.
I actually think this makes a lot of sense. But it is much easier to find a prostitute than a man who's soliciting.
And at least, imo, in the cases of the young, poor women that walk the streets--I think the men who come up and solicit are very much to blame. At least, especially, in the situation of my friend--who was both underage and addicted to drugs. She legally wasn't able to consent, and yet fully adult men who supposedly have fully mature brains went after her.
I remember the time vividly, because we'd both run away from home. And I know from my own experience, at the time, that I was solicited by people just for appearing to be someone who was on the streets.
I remember I would walk by this particular fish and chips shop, and it seemed so amazing that people could eat there, and then a man in probably his late fifties approached me, offering me a couple cans of dog food for my dog. He asked me if I wanted to work for him, cleaning his boat. I said I would think about it, so we went to his yacht club and walked out to the yacht to show it to me.
But then, he asked me if I 'play for pay,' and I think I asked him what that meant, and told him no. He said something about how he likes to go visit the islands out around there, and his girlfriend and he like to have an additional partner to go, and honestly that sounded the most interesting, to be able to go. I still told him no, though obviously the idea of sailing in a yacht, having food...being able to explore somewhere new...was appealing, compared to having to go back to just living on the street of the city.
Anyway--dude was probably going to murder me if I did. But then he asked me again, after I told him no--he just wanted to jerk off next to me, even if I was fully clothed. I still said no. I thought it was so stupid for this rich dude with anything and everything anyone could want, is going around finding teenage girls who are homeless to try to pay them for sex.
It's people like that who should be penalized for prostitution laws. I suppose I 'saved' him from falling to such lows though (at least with me--I doubt I was the first person he's ever done that whole thing with and who knows--maybe the others were on the bottom of the Sound.)
It will always stick in my mind how frivolous and misguided people can be--a man with so much more than other people, has to be kept from doing something wrong by a teenage girl on the street refusing his requests for prostitution.
That memory is probably one of most poignant (to me--I explained it horribly, but how I remember it) images of how money doesn't equate to social value or virtue--how those with more money do not have more virtue, and how capitalism doesn't work in such a way that the market follows social values--or else it's a symptom of society having very sick values (or both).
With my other friend, well--you could call it desperation. But there are people who choose to be prostitutes who have other choices. And I should specify it was a rare occasion--when the offer was right. It wasn't like a regular job. It was supplemental.
And the men who visited the strip clubs and escort services were probably (hopefully) a slightly different type of man than who goes and looks for people in desperate situations, to offer them money for sex (like poor teenage girls going about their lives).
I'll never be able to afford to buy a house where I grew up, especially as a single mother. My friend was able to provide for her daughter in ways many people cannot.
And that, imo, shows there is more wrong with the low wages women often make in traditionally female-dominated work, combined with the hardship of motherhood, combined with the cost of housing and rent. So imo that is more indicative of a problem with our society, and the opportunities that people have, and the safety nets.
I don't think it can be solved by harsher laws against prostitutes, though I certainly felt resentful at times that I never chose to pursue anything related to adult entertainment, just like many women who work hard their whole lives, and still end up in difficult place.
But this is a social problem--not the fault of prostitution. And it's the people who choose to spend their money on teenage girls who have addictions, or no food or safe place to rest who are at fault.
Everything I've described has gone on in places where prostitution is illegal, and the prostitute could be arrested.
(sorry it's kind of ranty, but I haven't had my coffee)
I guess my point is that poor people have to make very difficult choices every day. Prostitution might be one, but it's hardly the only one.
The solution, imo, is for society to work towards egalitarianism and against poverty--that is the only way that desperation will be less of a driving factor.
Edit: I also found this article about teen trafficking.
https://www.npr.org/2010/12/06/131757019/youth-radio-trafficked-teen-girls-describe-life-in-the-game
And I recently heard about a county that cracked down on human trafficking, where the Sheriff basically said he felt like the biggest monsters in the whole thing were the men who pay to exploit this kind of human misery. Apparently trafficking has gone up dramatically lately where I live. Apparently part of it might be related to resources for homeland security being more focused on swooping in on factories to get illegal immigrants that are abiding by the law (for higher numbers of deportations), rather than focusing on criminal activity and trafficking of immigrants.
But I guess I am divided about prostitution--my friend who bought the house after working in adult industries was actually the mother of another high school friend.
So I guess I see a big difference between the examples I talked about (underage soliciting) and also in the news article (with the forced sex slavery), and an adult woman who worked in places that did run legally (like stripping and escort businesses), and was able to buy a house for herself and her daughter.