INFPs, would you want something meaningful, practical, or just an enjoyable ordinary object, like a game or candy?
Orrr is it totally dependable on the person themselves, with no relation whatsoever to personality type?
Me:
* Something practical. Nothing random that clutters my house.
* Stay over and let's watch movies and have sex. Nothing more complicated than that.
My INFP ex-bf liked:
* Videogames, but not random ones, the ones specific from his wishlist (he is also against random clutter).
* Tabletop roleplaying books (from wishlist, not random).
* Clothes (his Si-Fi would get obsessed with whatever item I bought him and he would wear them non-stop. When I asked "will you ever take them off? you need to shower and change at some point" He'd reply "I can't take this off! How dare you! You got them for me!" Super emotionally attached. But they weren't random clothes, they were things he mentioned he
needed, so I bought them, not clutter)
* Quality Time: staying over, watching tv, sex, cooking together, playing videogames together, etc etc
As you can imagine, the practical stuff involves paying attention to what he mentions casually (or not so casually) that he wants.
I always make the cake from scratch, for both me and for the SO, cause I'm the official baker in every relationship, so. I don't buy stuff, I make it myself and that's meaningful enough. No presents. Just homemade cake & quality time and we're good to go.
The "enjoyable ordinary object" you mention is yourself the lovely human. I am not kidding or trying to be nice. This is the absolute truth.